BACKGROUND: International guidelines stress the importance of accurately discriminating between asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Although characteristic pathological features have been described for both conditions, their discriminatory power has never been systematically assessed. METHODS:Endobronchial biopsy (EBB) specimens from patients with a clear clinical diagnosis of asthma and COPD (50 per group) were examined by three pathologists in a double blind manner. They were asked to propose a pathological diagnosis of either asthma or COPD and to analyse qualitatively the most frequent abnormalities reported in the literature. RESULTS: The sensitivity and specificity of EBB ranged from 36% to 48% and from 56% to 79%, respectively. Eosinophils strongly biased the pathological diagnoses in favour of asthma, whereas their estimated prevalence was similar (11-37% in asthma and 13-41% in COPD). Metaplasia (11-39% in COPD, 1-18% in asthma) and epithelial inflammation (28-61% in COPD, 11-38% in asthma) tended to be specific to COPD, whereas epithelial desquamation (80-98% in asthma, 61-88% in COPD) and basement membrane thickening (71-94% in asthma, 53-88% in COPD) tended to be associated with asthma. There was acceptable intra- and inter-observer agreement only for metaplasia and epithelial eosinophils. CONCLUSIONS: Specific histopathological features of asthma and COPD probably exist, but current routine analysis procedures to assess EBB specimens are not sufficiently discriminatory. This might be rectified by improving pathological definitions.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: International guidelines stress the importance of accurately discriminating between asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). Although characteristic pathological features have been described for both conditions, their discriminatory power has never been systematically assessed. METHODS: Endobronchial biopsy (EBB) specimens from patients with a clear clinical diagnosis of asthma and COPD (50 per group) were examined by three pathologists in a double blind manner. They were asked to propose a pathological diagnosis of either asthma or COPD and to analyse qualitatively the most frequent abnormalities reported in the literature. RESULTS: The sensitivity and specificity of EBB ranged from 36% to 48% and from 56% to 79%, respectively. Eosinophils strongly biased the pathological diagnoses in favour of asthma, whereas their estimated prevalence was similar (11-37% in asthma and 13-41% in COPD). Metaplasia (11-39% in COPD, 1-18% in asthma) and epithelial inflammation (28-61% in COPD, 11-38% in asthma) tended to be specific to COPD, whereas epithelial desquamation (80-98% in asthma, 61-88% in COPD) and basement membrane thickening (71-94% in asthma, 53-88% in COPD) tended to be associated with asthma. There was acceptable intra- and inter-observer agreement only for metaplasia and epithelial eosinophils. CONCLUSIONS: Specific histopathological features of asthma and COPD probably exist, but current routine analysis procedures to assess EBB specimens are not sufficiently discriminatory. This might be rectified by improving pathological definitions.
Authors: M Saetta; A Di Stefano; G Turato; F M Facchini; L Corbino; C E Mapp; P Maestrelli; A Ciaccia; L M Fabbri Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 1998-03 Impact factor: 21.405
Authors: A M Vignola; J Bousquet; P Chanez; R Gagliardo; A M Merendino; G Chiappara; G Bonsignore Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 1998-05 Impact factor: 21.405
Authors: P Chanez; A M Vignola; T O'Shaugnessy; I Enander; D Li; P K Jeffery; J Bousquet Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 1997-05 Impact factor: 21.405
Authors: J Y Lacoste; J Bousquet; P Chanez; T Van Vyve; J Simony-Lafontaine; N Lequeu; P Vic; I Enander; P Godard; F B Michel Journal: J Allergy Clin Immunol Date: 1993-10 Impact factor: 10.793
Authors: Maria Abdulrahim Arafah; Emad Raddaoui; Faisal Al Kassimi; Esam H Alhamad; Ahmed Amer Alboukai; Ahlam Abdullah Alshedoukhy; Abderrahman Ouban Journal: Ann Saudi Med Date: 2018 Mar-Apr Impact factor: 1.526
Authors: Jeroen J W Liesker; Nick H Ten Hacken; Mieke Zeinstra-Smith; Steven R Rutgers; Dirkje S Postma; Wim Timens Journal: Int J Chron Obstruct Pulmon Dis Date: 2009-04-15
Authors: Feisal A Al-Kassimi; Esam H Alhamad; Mohammed S Al-Hajjaj; Abdullah A Abba; Emad Raddaoui; Shaffi A Shaikh Journal: Ann Thorac Med Date: 2012-10 Impact factor: 2.219
Authors: Fatemeh Fattahi; Judith M Vonk; Nicole Bulkmans; Ruth Fleischeuer; Annette Gouw; Katrien Grünberg; Thais Mauad; Helmut Popper; Aloisio Felipe-Silva; Bart Vrugt; Joanne L Wright; Hui-Min Yang; Janwillem W H Kocks; Machteld N Hylkema; Dirkje S Postma; Wim Timens; Nick H T Ten Hacken Journal: Virchows Arch Date: 2015-09-14 Impact factor: 4.064