OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effectiveness of a lay delivered intervention to reduce Latino children's exposure to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS). The a priori hypothesis was that children living in households that were in the intervention group would have lower exposure over time than measurement only controls. DESIGN: A two group, randomised control trial was conducted. SETTING: Areas of San Diego county with a large Latino population. PARTICIPANTS: 143 Latino parent-child pairs. INTERVENTION: Trained bicultural and bilingual Latina lay community health advisors, or promotoras, conducted problem solving aimed at lowering the target child's exposure to ETS in the household. Six home and telephone sessions were delivered by the promotoras over a four month period. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Outcome measures were collected at baseline, immediately post-intervention, three months post-intervention, and 12 months post-intervention. Four outcomes were considered: (1) parent's paper-and-pencil reports of the child's past month exposure; (2) hair samples from the child analysed for past month nicotine; (3) hair samples from the child analysed for past month cotinine; and (4) per cent confirmed reducers. RESULTS: There were no significant condition-by-time interactions, the term indicative of a differential intervention effect. Significant or near significant time main effects were seen for children's hair cotinine, per cent confirmed reducers, and, in particular, parent reports of exposure. CONCLUSIONS: Applying a lay promotora model to deliver the behavioural problem solving intervention unfortunately was not effective. A likely explanation relates to the difficulty of delivering a relatively complex intervention by lay women untrained in behaviour change theory and research methods.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effectiveness of a lay delivered intervention to reduce Latino children's exposure to environmental tobacco smoke (ETS). The a priori hypothesis was that children living in households that were in the intervention group would have lower exposure over time than measurement only controls. DESIGN: A two group, randomised control trial was conducted. SETTING: Areas of San Diego county with a large Latino population. PARTICIPANTS: 143 Latino parent-child pairs. INTERVENTION: Trained bicultural and bilingual Latina lay community health advisors, or promotoras, conducted problem solving aimed at lowering the target child's exposure to ETS in the household. Six home and telephone sessions were delivered by the promotoras over a four month period. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Outcome measures were collected at baseline, immediately post-intervention, three months post-intervention, and 12 months post-intervention. Four outcomes were considered: (1) parent's paper-and-pencil reports of the child's past month exposure; (2) hair samples from the child analysed for past month nicotine; (3) hair samples from the child analysed for past month cotinine; and (4) per cent confirmed reducers. RESULTS: There were no significant condition-by-time interactions, the term indicative of a differential intervention effect. Significant or near significant time main effects were seen for children's hair cotinine, per cent confirmed reducers, and, in particular, parent reports of exposure. CONCLUSIONS: Applying a lay promotora model to deliver the behavioural problem solving intervention unfortunately was not effective. A likely explanation relates to the difficulty of delivering a relatively complex intervention by lay women untrained in behaviour change theory and research methods.
Authors: Guadalupe Ortega; Cristina Castellà; Carlos Martín-Cantera; Jose L Ballvé; Estela Díaz; Marc Saez; Juan Lozano; Lourdes Rofes; Concepció Morera; Antònia Barceló; Carmen Cabezas; Jose A Pascual; Raúl Pérez-Ortuño; Esteve Saltó; Araceli Valverde; Mireia Jané Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2010-12-20 Impact factor: 3.295
Authors: Bradley N Collins; E Paul Wileyto; Melbourne F Hovell; Uma S Nair; Karen Jaffe; Natalie M Tolley; Janet Audrain-McGovern Journal: Transl Behav Med Date: 2011-09 Impact factor: 3.046