OBJECTIVES: To compare cotrimoxazole and eflornithine as primary treatment for first-episode Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP). DESIGN: Prospective open-labelled study. METHODS: Patients were randomized to eflornithine (400 mg/kg daily, as a continuous intravenous infusion) or cotrimoxazole (3.84 g twice daily, intravenously) for 14 days. RESULTS: Only 39% of patients treated with eflornithine (20 out of 51) and 40% of those given cotrimoxazole (nine out of 47) successfully completed therapy. Although 12 out of the 36 patients with confirmed PCP were treated successfully with eflornithine, significantly more patients were withdrawn from the eflornithine group because of therapy failure (25 out of 51 versus 10 out of 47, P = 0.007). This significant difference persisted in patients in whom a diagnosis of PCP was confirmed histologically (19 out of 33 versus seven out of 27, P = 0.03). Significantly more patients were withdrawn from cotrimoxazole because of serious drug-related side-effects (38 versus 12%, P = 0.005). CONCLUSIONS:Eflornithine (400 mg/kg daily) is less effective than cotrimoxazole (7.68 g daily) as treatment for first-episode PCP. Eflornithine does have activity against P. carinii in humans.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVES: To compare cotrimoxazole and eflornithine as primary treatment for first-episode Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP). DESIGN: Prospective open-labelled study. METHODS:Patients were randomized to eflornithine (400 mg/kg daily, as a continuous intravenous infusion) or cotrimoxazole (3.84 g twice daily, intravenously) for 14 days. RESULTS: Only 39% of patients treated with eflornithine (20 out of 51) and 40% of those given cotrimoxazole (nine out of 47) successfully completed therapy. Although 12 out of the 36 patients with confirmed PCP were treated successfully with eflornithine, significantly more patients were withdrawn from the eflornithine group because of therapy failure (25 out of 51 versus 10 out of 47, P = 0.007). This significant difference persisted in patients in whom a diagnosis of PCP was confirmed histologically (19 out of 33 versus seven out of 27, P = 0.03). Significantly more patients were withdrawn from cotrimoxazole because of serious drug-related side-effects (38 versus 12%, P = 0.005). CONCLUSIONS:Eflornithine (400 mg/kg daily) is less effective than cotrimoxazole (7.68 g daily) as treatment for first-episode PCP. Eflornithine does have activity against P. carinii in humans.