Rachel I Gafni1, Jeffrey Baron. 1. Unit on Growth and Development, Developmental Endocrinology Branch, National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland 20892-1862, USA. gafnir@mail.nih.gov
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) is increasingly used to evaluate children for osteoporosis. However, the interpretation of pediatric DEXA is complicated by growth and development. Because most DEXA scans are performed on adults, we hypothesized that physicians who interpret DEXA may not be aware of these pediatric issues, potentially leading to misdiagnosis. STUDY DESIGN: Children (n=34, aged 4-17 years) diagnosed with low bone mineral density (BMD) based on a DEXA scan were referred for possible inclusion in a childhood osteoporosis protocol. The referral DEXA scans were analyzed for accuracy. RESULTS: Thirty (88%) of the scans had at least one error in interpretation. The most frequent error (62%) was use of T-score (SD score compared with young adults) to diagnose osteoporosis, which is inappropriate for children. Other errors included use of a reference database that does not consider gender or ethnic differences (21%), incorrect bone map (21%), inattention to short stature (15%), and other measurement or statistical error (12%). After correcting for these errors, 53% had normal BMD, whereas only 26% retained the diagnosis of low BMD. The remaining 21% could not be given a definitive diagnosis. CONCLUSION: In children, the diagnosis of osteoporosis is often due to misinterpretation of a DEXA scan.
OBJECTIVE: Dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) is increasingly used to evaluate children for osteoporosis. However, the interpretation of pediatric DEXA is complicated by growth and development. Because most DEXA scans are performed on adults, we hypothesized that physicians who interpret DEXA may not be aware of these pediatric issues, potentially leading to misdiagnosis. STUDY DESIGN:Children (n=34, aged 4-17 years) diagnosed with low bone mineral density (BMD) based on a DEXA scan were referred for possible inclusion in a childhood osteoporosis protocol. The referral DEXA scans were analyzed for accuracy. RESULTS: Thirty (88%) of the scans had at least one error in interpretation. The most frequent error (62%) was use of T-score (SD score compared with young adults) to diagnose osteoporosis, which is inappropriate for children. Other errors included use of a reference database that does not consider gender or ethnic differences (21%), incorrect bone map (21%), inattention to short stature (15%), and other measurement or statistical error (12%). After correcting for these errors, 53% had normal BMD, whereas only 26% retained the diagnosis of low BMD. The remaining 21% could not be given a definitive diagnosis. CONCLUSION: In children, the diagnosis of osteoporosis is often due to misinterpretation of a DEXA scan.
Authors: Wei Zhou; Lisa Langsetmo; Claudie Berger; Jonathan D Adachi; Alexandra Papaioannou; George Ioannidis; Colin Webber; Stephanie A Atkinson; Wojciech P Olszynski; Jacques P Brown; David A Hanley; Robert Josse; Nancy Kreiger; Jerilynn Prior; Stephanie Kaiser; Susan Kirkland; David Goltzman; Kenneth Shawn Davison Journal: J Clin Densitom Date: 2010-05-31 Impact factor: 2.617
Authors: Kyung Hee Yi; Jin Soon Hwang; Eun Young Kim; Jun Ah Lee; Dong Ho Kim; Jung Sub Lim Journal: J Bone Miner Metab Date: 2013-07-06 Impact factor: 2.626
Authors: J Chenbhanich; C Thongprayoon; A Atsawarungruangkit; T Phupitakphol; W Cheungpasitporn Journal: Osteoporos Int Date: 2017-11-06 Impact factor: 4.507