BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Since the 1990s, as many women as men have been entering and graduating from medical schools in Western countries. Up to date, prospective studies of physicians' career paths are lacking. This paper presents the data of the first assessment of a longitudinal survey of a cohort of Swiss medical school graduates, evaluated with regard to how gender and personality traits contribute to their academic achievement and further career planning. METHODS: In 2001, 719 graduate students (52.9% females, 47.1% males) returned a postal questionnaire comprising sections on personality traits, career motivation, and career planning. RESULTS: Female graduates scored higher on traits such as helpfulness, relationship consciousness, empathy, family responsibility, and job security. Male students scored higher on traits such as independence, decisiveness, self-confidence, activity, income, and prestige. Women were further advanced in the writing of their thesis (p = 0.04), chose different topics (p <0.001), and had more often decided in which field they wished to specialise (p =.02). Women preferred fields with intensive patient contact (p <0.01), men tended to specialise more in instrumentally oriented and high-technology medicine (p <.001). The regression model revealed that, apart from gender (being female), instrumentality and extrinsic career motivation predict advanced academic achievement, whereas self-esteem and intrinsic career motivation influence the choice of speciality. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that women plan their career more purposefully than men, and that not only gender but also personality traits and career motivation play an important role in academic achievement and career planning.
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Since the 1990s, as many women as men have been entering and graduating from medical schools in Western countries. Up to date, prospective studies of physicians' career paths are lacking. This paper presents the data of the first assessment of a longitudinal survey of a cohort of Swiss medical school graduates, evaluated with regard to how gender and personality traits contribute to their academic achievement and further career planning. METHODS: In 2001, 719 graduate students (52.9% females, 47.1% males) returned a postal questionnaire comprising sections on personality traits, career motivation, and career planning. RESULTS: Female graduates scored higher on traits such as helpfulness, relationship consciousness, empathy, family responsibility, and job security. Male students scored higher on traits such as independence, decisiveness, self-confidence, activity, income, and prestige. Women were further advanced in the writing of their thesis (p = 0.04), chose different topics (p <0.001), and had more often decided in which field they wished to specialise (p =.02). Women preferred fields with intensive patient contact (p <0.01), men tended to specialise more in instrumentally oriented and high-technology medicine (p <.001). The regression model revealed that, apart from gender (being female), instrumentality and extrinsic career motivation predict advanced academic achievement, whereas self-esteem and intrinsic career motivation influence the choice of speciality. CONCLUSIONS: The results indicate that women plan their career more purposefully than men, and that not only gender but also personality traits and career motivation play an important role in academic achievement and career planning.
Authors: Richard Klaghofer; Martina Stamm; Claus Buddeberg; Georg Bauer; Oliver Hämmig; Michaela Knecht; Barbara Buddeberg-Fischer Journal: Int Arch Occup Environ Health Date: 2010-06-12 Impact factor: 3.015
Authors: Barbara Buddeberg-Fischer; Richard Klaghofer; Martina Stamm; Johannes Siegrist; Claus Buddeberg Journal: Int Arch Occup Environ Health Date: 2008-02-12 Impact factor: 3.015
Authors: Barbara Buddeberg-Fischer; Martina Stamm; Claus Buddeberg; Richard Klaghofer Journal: Int Arch Occup Environ Health Date: 2009-09-25 Impact factor: 3.015
Authors: R E Cserepes; A Bugán; T Korösi; B Toth; S Rösner; T Strowitzki; T Wischmann Journal: Geburtshilfe Frauenheilkd Date: 2014-11 Impact factor: 2.915
Authors: Ana Delgado; Lorena Saletti-Cuesta; Luis Andrés López-Fernández; Juan de Dios de Dios Luna; Inmaculada Mateo-Rodriguez Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2011-02-28 Impact factor: 2.655
Authors: Saima Diderichsen; Eva E Johansson; Petra Verdonk; Toine Lagro-Janssen; Katarina Hamberg Journal: BMC Med Educ Date: 2013-03-08 Impact factor: 2.463