PURPOSE: To examine data from a natural experiment resulting from a change made in the confidentiality agreement midway through a randomized, longitudinal, controlled trial to prevent or delay adolescent alcohol use. The investigators explored the impact of the change on adolescents' rates of participation and affirmative responses to a question on suicidal thoughts. METHODS:Adolescents 12-17 years old were administered a question on suicidal thoughts as part of a confidential exit interview after a general health examination with their primary care provider. After administration to 263 adolescents, the exit interview was made conditionally confidential with the remaining 181 adolescents. The revised consent form and protocol stipulated that researchers would reveal to appropriate professionals and parents any adolescent indicating suicidal thoughts. Prevalence estimates for the suicidal thoughts question and study participation rates were computed for conditions both before and after the change. RESULTS: Fewer adolescents responded affirmatively to the suicidal thoughts question when they were recruited using the revised (1%) than the original (8%) consent form and protocol (p=.001). The revised confidentiality agreement did not affect participation rates. CONCLUSIONS: Adolescents who assent to participate in research studies may be less likely to disclose personal information regarding suicidal thoughts if they know that their disclosure may result in a break in confidentiality. Specific guidelines are needed for conditional and unconditional confidentiality agreements to study mental health in adolescent longitudinal prevention research.
RCT Entities:
PURPOSE: To examine data from a natural experiment resulting from a change made in the confidentiality agreement midway through a randomized, longitudinal, controlled trial to prevent or delay adolescent alcohol use. The investigators explored the impact of the change on adolescents' rates of participation and affirmative responses to a question on suicidal thoughts. METHODS: Adolescents 12-17 years old were administered a question on suicidal thoughts as part of a confidential exit interview after a general health examination with their primary care provider. After administration to 263 adolescents, the exit interview was made conditionally confidential with the remaining 181 adolescents. The revised consent form and protocol stipulated that researchers would reveal to appropriate professionals and parents any adolescent indicating suicidal thoughts. Prevalence estimates for the suicidal thoughts question and study participation rates were computed for conditions both before and after the change. RESULTS: Fewer adolescents responded affirmatively to the suicidal thoughts question when they were recruited using the revised (1%) than the original (8%) consent form and protocol (p=.001). The revised confidentiality agreement did not affect participation rates. CONCLUSIONS: Adolescents who assent to participate in research studies may be less likely to disclose personal information regarding suicidal thoughts if they know that their disclosure may result in a break in confidentiality. Specific guidelines are needed for conditional and unconditional confidentiality agreements to study mental health in adolescent longitudinal prevention research.
Entities:
Keywords:
Biomedical and Behavioral Research; Empirical Approach
Authors: M Catherin Freier; Duane McBride; Gary Hopkins; Talin Babikian; Lloyd Richardson; Herb Helm Journal: J Urban Health Date: 2005-09 Impact factor: 3.671
Authors: Shawn Marschall-Lévesque; Natalie Castellanos-Ryan; Sophie Parent; Johanne Renaud; Frank Vitaro; Michel Boivin; Richard E Tremblay; Jean R Séguin Journal: J Adolesc Health Date: 2016-11-30 Impact factor: 5.012
Authors: Miguel Ruiz-Canela; Cristina Lopez-del Burgo; Silvia Carlos; Maria Calatrava; Carlos Beltramo; Alfonso Osorio; Jokin de Irala Journal: BMC Med Ethics Date: 2013-01-03 Impact factor: 2.652