J Cwikel1, K Ilan, B Chudakov. 1. Center for Women's Health Studies and Promotion and Department of Social Work. Faculty of Health Sciences, Ben Gurion University of the Negev, PO Box 653, Beer Sheva 84105, Israel. jcwikel@bgumail.bgu.ac.il
Abstract
STUDY OBJECTIVES: This study examined working conditions, reported morbidity, symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression and their relation to an index of occupational health risk among women working in brothels in Israel. DESIGN: Personal structured interviews with a scale of occupational risk that included seven self report items reflecting past and present morbidity and symptoms. PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING: A purposive sample of 55 women in three cities in Israel, between the ages of 18-38. MAIN RESULTS: Most (82%) women were trafficked into Israel to work illegally in prostitution, effectively deriving them of access to discretionary health care. A third of the sample (32%) had a high score (between 3 to 6) on the index of occupational risk factors. A high score was not related to recent physician or gynaecological visits and was more common among illegal workers than those with residence status. A set of regression analyses showed that the most significant predictors of reporting a high level of occupational risk symptoms were starting sex work at an early age, the number of hours worked in a day, a history of suicide attempts and PTSD symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: High occupational risk was found to be unrelated to recent physician or gynaecological visits, indicating that these visits were most probably controlled by the brothel owners and not by medical need as perceived by the women themselves. Furthermore, occupational risk factors were associated with some of the working and background conditions reported by women brothel workers. There is an urgent need for medical care for this high risk group.
STUDY OBJECTIVES: This study examined working conditions, reported morbidity, symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression and their relation to an index of occupational health risk among women working in brothels in Israel. DESIGN: Personal structured interviews with a scale of occupational risk that included seven self report items reflecting past and present morbidity and symptoms. PARTICIPANTS AND SETTING: A purposive sample of 55 women in three cities in Israel, between the ages of 18-38. MAIN RESULTS: Most (82%) women were trafficked into Israel to work illegally in prostitution, effectively deriving them of access to discretionary health care. A third of the sample (32%) had a high score (between 3 to 6) on the index of occupational risk factors. A high score was not related to recent physician or gynaecological visits and was more common among illegal workers than those with residence status. A set of regression analyses showed that the most significant predictors of reporting a high level of occupational risk symptoms were starting sex work at an early age, the number of hours worked in a day, a history of suicide attempts and PTSD symptoms. CONCLUSIONS: High occupational risk was found to be unrelated to recent physician or gynaecological visits, indicating that these visits were most probably controlled by the brothel owners and not by medical need as perceived by the women themselves. Furthermore, occupational risk factors were associated with some of the working and background conditions reported by women brothel workers. There is an urgent need for medical care for this high risk group.
Authors: Monica D Ulibarri; Steffanie A Strathdee; Remedios Lozada; Carlos Magis-Rodriguez; Hortensia Amaro; Patricia O'Campo; Thomas L Patterson Journal: Violence Against Women Date: 2014-03-30
Authors: Juan Manuel Millan-Alanis; Farid Carranza-Navarro; Humberto de León-Gutiérrez; Paloma C Leyva-Camacho; Andrea Fernanda Guerrero-Medrano; Francisco J Barrera; Leticia Elizabeth Garza Lopez; Erasmo Saucedo-Uribe Journal: Arch Womens Ment Health Date: 2021-06-10 Impact factor: 3.633
Authors: Michele R Decker; Heather L McCauley; Dusita Phuengsamran; Surang Janyam; Jay G Silverman Journal: J Epidemiol Community Health Date: 2010-06-01 Impact factor: 3.710
Authors: Jhumka Gupta; Anita Raj; Michele R Decker; Elizabeth Reed; Jay G Silverman Journal: Int J Gynaecol Obstet Date: 2009-07-21 Impact factor: 3.561
Authors: Monica D Ulibarri; Shirley J Semple; Swati Rao; Steffanie A Strathdee; Miguel A Fraga-Vallejo; Jesus Bucardo; Adela De la Torre; Juan Salázar-Reyna; Prisci Orozovich; Hugo S Staines-Orozco; Hortensia Amaro; Carlos Magis-Rodríguez; Thomas L Patterson Journal: Violence Vict Date: 2009
Authors: Kathleen N Deering; Avni Amin; Jean Shoveller; Ariel Nesbitt; Claudia Garcia-Moreno; Putu Duff; Elena Argento; Kate Shannon Journal: Am J Public Health Date: 2014-03-13 Impact factor: 9.308
Authors: Monica D Ulibarri; Sarah P Hiller; Remedios Lozada; M Gudelia Rangel; Jamila K Stockman; Jay G Silverman; Victoria D Ojeda Journal: J Environ Public Health Date: 2013-05-12