Digitalis and heart failure: does digitalis really produce beneficial effects through a positive inotropic action?

Although digitalis was introduced to medicine long ago, the drug is still extensively used in clinical practice today. Opinions on its mechanism of action have undergone much change in the course of time, and the way in which cardiovascular effects are produced is still not completely clear. Limitations and contraindications for the use of digitalis substances are reported, especially in the treatment of ischemic heart disease. Preliminary data regarding the effects of digitalis on the diastolic phase are unfavorable, although the relationship between digitalis and diastolic function ought to be studied in greater depth in various clinical conditions. In spite of many recent trials, the old question of the usefulness of digitalis in the chronic treatment of patients in sinus rhythm and heart failure is still debated. An important clinical benefit in the chronic use of digitalis appears restricted to a relatively small proportion of patients with severe congestive heart failure, while in the majority of chronically treated subjects the effects of the drug are scanty or insignificant. The beneficial effect of digitalis used chronically is essentially believed to be due to its positive inotropic action. Since the vagomimetic and the antiadrenergic effects of digitalis have been demonstrated to be independent from its inotropic action, they could be considered determinants of the clinical benefits of digitalis. These indirect effects may be useful in the control of the negative neuroendocrine response developing during congestive heart failure. Thus the statement that digitalis is essentially an inotropic agent seems restrictive; its definition should reflect the favorable effects obtained in some cases of congestive heart failure rather than its various and contrasting underlying mechanisms of action.