PURPOSE: This study was designed to determine the proportion of patients with clinical stage I nonseminomatous germ cell tumors of the testis (NSGCTT) managed with surveillance after orchidectomy who have more advanced disease and, therefore, require further treatment, the time to progression, the sites of progression, and the efficacy of treatment delayed until progression was recognized. PATIENTS AND METHODS: One hundred five patients were observed prospectively without further treatment after orchidectomy and full clinical staging. Treatment was given immediately upon detection of marker-positive, clinical, or radiologic evidence of disease. RESULTS: Thirty-seven patients (35.2%) have required further therapy for disease progression, occurring from 2 to 21 months after diagnosis. Thirty-six patients have been successfully treated. Overall, 104 patients (99%) remain alive and free of disease at 12 to 121 months after orchidectomy. Progression occurred in the retroperitoneum in 25 of 37 patients who developed further disease on surveillance. The presence of vascular invasion in the primary tumor was predictive of an increased risk of progression. CONCLUSION: Surveillance is a valid alternative to immediate retroperitoneal lymph node dissection in patients with clinical stage I NSGCTT but should be recommended only under the close supervision of physicians experienced in the diagnosis and treatment of testicular cancer.
PURPOSE: This study was designed to determine the proportion of patients with clinical stage I nonseminomatous germ cell tumors of the testis (NSGCTT) managed with surveillance after orchidectomy who have more advanced disease and, therefore, require further treatment, the time to progression, the sites of progression, and the efficacy of treatment delayed until progression was recognized. PATIENTS AND METHODS: One hundred five patients were observed prospectively without further treatment after orchidectomy and full clinical staging. Treatment was given immediately upon detection of marker-positive, clinical, or radiologic evidence of disease. RESULTS: Thirty-seven patients (35.2%) have required further therapy for disease progression, occurring from 2 to 21 months after diagnosis. Thirty-six patients have been successfully treated. Overall, 104 patients (99%) remain alive and free of disease at 12 to 121 months after orchidectomy. Progression occurred in the retroperitoneum in 25 of 37 patients who developed further disease on surveillance. The presence of vascular invasion in the primary tumor was predictive of an increased risk of progression. CONCLUSION: Surveillance is a valid alternative to immediate retroperitoneal lymph node dissection in patients with clinical stage I NSGCTT but should be recommended only under the close supervision of physicians experienced in the diagnosis and treatment of testicular cancer.
Authors: Lori Wood; Christian Kollmannsberger; Michael Jewett; Peter Chung; Sebastian Hotte; Martin O'Malley; Joan Sweet; Lynn Anson-Cartwright; Eric Winquist; Scott North; Scott Tyldesley; Jeremy Sturgeon; Mary Gospodarowicz; Roanne Segal; Tina Cheng; Peter Venner; Malcolm Moore; Peter Albers; Robert Huddart; Craig Nichols; Padraig Warde Journal: Can Urol Assoc J Date: 2010-04 Impact factor: 1.862