BACKGROUND: Surgical airway intervention is occasionally necessary due to contraindicated or failed endotracheal intubation. In cricothyroidotomy patients, a choice exists between continued long-term ventilation via the cricothyroidotomy portal or conversion to tracheostomy. We examined whether conversion to tracheostomy reduces the risk of acute complications. METHODS: We retrospectively identified 46 patients with cricothyroidotomies performed at our level I trauma center over a 63-month period. We reviewed the success rate, indications, etiology, and complications. RESULTS: An airway was obtained in all cases. The most common indicator for surgical airway intervention was unsuccessful endotracheal intubation. The cause of death among nonsurvivors was not due to airway complications. Of the 15 surviving patients, 8 had conversions to tracheostomy and 7 patients did not have conversions but had decannulations. The converted group had a greater percentage of acute complications than the nonconverted group. CONCLUSION: Rate of acute complications with prolonged ventilation via cricothyroidotomy portal is equal to, if not lower than, via converted tracheostomy. Cricothyroidotomy in trauma patients may be used long term without any increase in acute complications.
BACKGROUND: Surgical airway intervention is occasionally necessary due to contraindicated or failed endotracheal intubation. In cricothyroidotomy patients, a choice exists between continued long-term ventilation via the cricothyroidotomy portal or conversion to tracheostomy. We examined whether conversion to tracheostomy reduces the risk of acute complications. METHODS: We retrospectively identified 46 patients with cricothyroidotomies performed at our level I trauma center over a 63-month period. We reviewed the success rate, indications, etiology, and complications. RESULTS: An airway was obtained in all cases. The most common indicator for surgical airway intervention was unsuccessful endotracheal intubation. The cause of death among nonsurvivors was not due to airway complications. Of the 15 surviving patients, 8 had conversions to tracheostomy and 7 patients did not have conversions but had decannulations. The converted group had a greater percentage of acute complications than the nonconverted group. CONCLUSION: Rate of acute complications with prolonged ventilation via cricothyroidotomy portal is equal to, if not lower than, via converted tracheostomy. Cricothyroidotomy in traumapatients may be used long term without any increase in acute complications.