PURPOSE: To examine evidence for effectiveness of anteromesial temporal lobe and localized neocortical resections for disabling complex partial seizures. METHODS: Systemic review and analysis of the literature since 1990. RESULTS: One intention-to-treat Class I randomized controlled trial of surgery for mesial temporal lobe epilepsy found that 58% of patients randomized to be evaluated for surgical therapy (64% of those who received surgery) were free of disabling seizures and 10 to 15% were unimproved at the end of 1 year, compared with 8% free of disabling seizures in the group randomized to continued medical therapy. There was a significant improvement in quantitative quality-of-life scores and a trend toward better social function at the end of 1 year for patients in the surgical group, no surgical mortality, and infrequent morbidity. Twenty-four Class IV series of temporal lobe resections yielded essentially identical results. There are similar Class IV results for localized neocortical resections; no Class I or II studies are available. CONCLUSIONS: A single Class I study and 24 Class IV studies indicate that the benefits of anteromesial temporal lobe resection for disabling complex partial seizures is greater than continued treatment with antiepileptic drugs, and the risks are at least comparable. For patients who are compromised by such seizures, referral to an epilepsy surgery center should be strongly considered. Further studies are needed to determine if neocortical seizures benefit from surgery, and whether early surgical intervention should be the treatment of choice for certain surgically remediable epileptic syndromes.
RCT Entities:
PURPOSE: To examine evidence for effectiveness of anteromesial temporal lobe and localized neocortical resections for disabling complex partial seizures. METHODS: Systemic review and analysis of the literature since 1990. RESULTS: One intention-to-treat Class I randomized controlled trial of surgery for mesial temporal lobe epilepsy found that 58% of patients randomized to be evaluated for surgical therapy (64% of those who received surgery) were free of disabling seizures and 10 to 15% were unimproved at the end of 1 year, compared with 8% free of disabling seizures in the group randomized to continued medical therapy. There was a significant improvement in quantitative quality-of-life scores and a trend toward better social function at the end of 1 year for patients in the surgical group, no surgical mortality, and infrequent morbidity. Twenty-four Class IV series of temporal lobe resections yielded essentially identical results. There are similar Class IV results for localized neocortical resections; no Class I or II studies are available. CONCLUSIONS: A single Class I study and 24 Class IV studies indicate that the benefits of anteromesial temporal lobe resection for disabling complex partial seizures is greater than continued treatment with antiepileptic drugs, and the risks are at least comparable. For patients who are compromised by such seizures, referral to an epilepsy surgery center should be strongly considered. Further studies are needed to determine if neocortical seizures benefit from surgery, and whether early surgical intervention should be the treatment of choice for certain surgically remediable epileptic syndromes.
Authors: C A Schevon; J Cappell; R Emerson; J Isler; P Grieve; R Goodman; G McKhann; H Weiner; W Doyle; R Kuzniecky; O Devinsky; F Gilliam Journal: Neuroimage Date: 2007-01-16 Impact factor: 6.556
Authors: Kjell Heuser; Tore Eid; Fredrik Lauritzen; Anna E Thoren; Gry F Vindedal; Erik Taubøll; Leif Gjerstad; Dennis D Spencer; Ole P Ottersen; Erlend A Nagelhus; Nihal C de Lanerolle Journal: J Neuropathol Exp Neurol Date: 2012-09 Impact factor: 3.685
Authors: Richard Q Loi; Kelly M Leyden; Akshara Balachandra; Vedang Uttarwar; Donald J Hagler; Brianna M Paul; Anders M Dale; Nathan S White; Carrie R McDonald Journal: Epilepsia Date: 2016-10-13 Impact factor: 5.864
Authors: Leonardo Bonilha; Jens H Jensen; Nathaniel Baker; Jesse Breedlove; Travis Nesland; Jack J Lin; Daniel L Drane; Amit M Saindane; Jeffrey R Binder; Ruben I Kuzniecky Journal: Neurology Date: 2015-04-08 Impact factor: 9.910