X Ayral1, J P Bonvarlet, J Simonnet, G R Auleley, M Dougados, P Ravaud. 1. Service de Rhumatologie B, Hôpital Cochin, Assistance Publique-Hôpitaux de Paris,Université René Descartes, Paris, France. xavier.ayral@cch.ap-hop-paris.fr <xavier.ayral@cch.ap-hop-paris.fr>
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of partial medial meniscectomy on tibiofemoral joint space width (JSW). DESIGN: Thirty-seven patients (mean age: 51 years), suffering from medial meniscal lesions, (post-traumatic (n=22) or degenerative (n=15)), and requiring arthroscopic partial meniscectomy, were enrolled in a prospective, controlled study. Bilateral weight-bearing radiographs in extended and flexed position were performed in the same Radiology Unit just before and 2 days after meniscectomy. During arthroscopy, the extent of meniscectomy was evaluated in percentage and medial chondropathy was quantified using the Société Française d'Arthroscopie (SFA) scoring system (SFA score: 0-100). Medial chondropathy was absent or mild (mean SFA score: 8+/-13). Meniscectomy removed an average of 61% of the posterior third of the medial meniscus, 51% of the middle third and 22% of the anterior third. Radiographs, before and after meniscectomy, were read singly and were analyzed by a single reader unaware of patient identity and date of radiographs. Medial JSW was measured at the narrowest point of the medial compartment using a 0.1mm graduated magnifying glass. RESULTS: Comparison of JSW before and after meniscectomy did not show any statistically significant difference (mm): 0.01+/-0.43 (p=0.83) and -0.05+/-0.56 (p=0.66) in the extended and flexed views, respectively. CONCLUSION: This preliminary study suggests that partial medial meniscectomy does not influence tibiofemoral JSW on weight-bearing X-rays. Consequently, joint space narrowing appearing after partial meniscectomy should lead to seeking postmeniscectomy cartilage degradation rather than being attributed to removal of the meniscus.
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to evaluate the influence of partial medial meniscectomy on tibiofemoral joint space width (JSW). DESIGN: Thirty-seven patients (mean age: 51 years), suffering from medial meniscal lesions, (post-traumatic (n=22) or degenerative (n=15)), and requiring arthroscopic partial meniscectomy, were enrolled in a prospective, controlled study. Bilateral weight-bearing radiographs in extended and flexed position were performed in the same Radiology Unit just before and 2 days after meniscectomy. During arthroscopy, the extent of meniscectomy was evaluated in percentage and medial chondropathy was quantified using the Société Française d'Arthroscopie (SFA) scoring system (SFA score: 0-100). Medial chondropathy was absent or mild (mean SFA score: 8+/-13). Meniscectomy removed an average of 61% of the posterior third of the medial meniscus, 51% of the middle third and 22% of the anterior third. Radiographs, before and after meniscectomy, were read singly and were analyzed by a single reader unaware of patient identity and date of radiographs. Medial JSW was measured at the narrowest point of the medial compartment using a 0.1mm graduated magnifying glass. RESULTS: Comparison of JSW before and after meniscectomy did not show any statistically significant difference (mm): 0.01+/-0.43 (p=0.83) and -0.05+/-0.56 (p=0.66) in the extended and flexed views, respectively. CONCLUSION: This preliminary study suggests that partial medial meniscectomy does not influence tibiofemoral JSW on weight-bearing X-rays. Consequently, joint space narrowing appearing after partial meniscectomy should lead to seeking postmeniscectomy cartilage degradation rather than being attributed to removal of the meniscus.
Authors: Morgan H Jones; Kurt P Spindler; Jack T Andrish; Charles L Cox; Warren R Dunn; Jeff Duryea; Carol L Duong; David C Flanigan; Braden C Fleming; Laura J Huston; Christopher C Kaeding; Matthew J Matava; Nancy A Obuchowski; Heidi L Oksendahl; Richard D Parker; Erica A Scaramuzza; Matthew V Smith; Carl S Winalski; Rick W Wright; Emily K Reinke Journal: Am J Sports Med Date: 2018-02-02 Impact factor: 6.202
Authors: M-J Berthiaume; J-P Raynauld; J Martel-Pelletier; F Labonté; G Beaudoin; D A Bloch; D Choquette; B Haraoui; R D Altman; M Hochberg; J M Meyer; G A Cline; J-P Pelletier Journal: Ann Rheum Dis Date: 2004-09-16 Impact factor: 19.103
Authors: Karen A Beattie; Jeffrey Duryea; Margaret Pui; John O'Neill; Pauline Boulos; Colin E Webber; Felix Eckstein; Jonathan D Adachi Journal: BMC Musculoskelet Disord Date: 2008-09-08 Impact factor: 2.362