OBJECTIVES: To assess adherence to a 1996 health policy change, which discontinued mandatory tuberculin skin testing (TST) of new entrants to NYC primary schools and continued mandatory testing of new entrants to secondary schools. METHODS: The proportion tested before (1991-1995) and after (1996-1998) the change in health policy was determined. Factors associated with TST positivity and the cost of continued testing were assessed. RESULTS: A total of 76.6% of 551 636 new entrants to primary schools were tested in 1991-1995; slightly fewer, 71.1% of 339 958, were tested in 1996- 1998. Among new entrants to secondary schools, 31.0% of 106 463 were tested in 1991-1995 and 51.4% of 53 762 were tested in 1996-1998. The proportion who were TST-positive continued to decrease after 1996 to 1.2% among primary and 9.7% among secondary schoolchildren in 1998. Older age and birth outside the United States were associated with TST positivity. The estimated minimum cost of continued testing in primary schools was $123 152 per tuberculosis case prevented. CONCLUSION: An approach aimed at reducing testing of children at low risk for latent tuberculosis infection did not decrease testing of younger children. More important, older children who were more likely to be born in countries of high tuberculosis incidence were not tested. Additional efforts are needed to increase awareness among medical and school personnel to decrease testing among children who do not have risk factors for latent tuberculosis infection and to increase tuberculin testing of children who are entering school for the first time at the secondary level and do have risk factors for tuberculosis infection.
OBJECTIVES: To assess adherence to a 1996 health policy change, which discontinued mandatory tuberculin skin testing (TST) of new entrants to NYC primary schools and continued mandatory testing of new entrants to secondary schools. METHODS: The proportion tested before (1991-1995) and after (1996-1998) the change in health policy was determined. Factors associated with TST positivity and the cost of continued testing were assessed. RESULTS: A total of 76.6% of 551 636 new entrants to primary schools were tested in 1991-1995; slightly fewer, 71.1% of 339 958, were tested in 1996- 1998. Among new entrants to secondary schools, 31.0% of 106 463 were tested in 1991-1995 and 51.4% of 53 762 were tested in 1996-1998. The proportion who were TST-positive continued to decrease after 1996 to 1.2% among primary and 9.7% among secondary schoolchildren in 1998. Older age and birth outside the United States were associated with TST positivity. The estimated minimum cost of continued testing in primary schools was $123 152 per tuberculosis case prevented. CONCLUSION: An approach aimed at reducing testing of children at low risk for latent tuberculosis infection did not decrease testing of younger children. More important, older children who were more likely to be born in countries of high tuberculosis incidence were not tested. Additional efforts are needed to increase awareness among medical and school personnel to decrease testing among children who do not have risk factors for latent tuberculosis infection and to increase tuberculin testing of children who are entering school for the first time at the secondary level and do have risk factors for tuberculosis infection.
Authors: James D Mancuso; David Tribble; Gerald H Mazurek; Yuanzhang Li; Cara Olsen; Naomi E Aronson; Lawrence Geiter; Donald Goodwin; Lisa W Keep Journal: Clin Infect Dis Date: 2011-08-01 Impact factor: 9.079
Authors: Benjamin L Laskin; Jens Goebel; Jeffrey R Starke; Daniel P Schauer; Mark H Eckman Journal: Am J Kidney Dis Date: 2012-07-10 Impact factor: 8.860
Authors: Gabriella S Lamb; Andrea T Cruz; Elizabeth A Camp; Michelle Javier; Jessica Montour; Tamisha Piper; Umair A Shah; Jeffrey R Starke Journal: Emerg Infect Dis Date: 2020-08 Impact factor: 6.883