BACKGROUND: The inappropriate closure of the vocal cords is characteristic of vocal cord dysfunction (VCD). These patients present with wheezing and frequently receive a misdiagnosis of asthma. OBJECTIVE: To demonstrate the ability of computed tomography (CT) scored for the presence and extent of sinus disease and markers of inflammation to distinguish patients with VCD from patients with asthma. METHODS: Comparisons of 13 patients with VCD were made to 77 patients presenting to the emergency room with acute asthma, 31 non-acute asthmatic patients, and 65 nonasthmatic controls. Evaluation consisted of exhaled nitric oxide gas (eNO), circulating eosinophils, and total serum immunoglobulin (Ig)E, as well as the sinus CT scan. RESULTS: Extensive sinus CT changes were present in 23 of 74 acute asthmatic patients, 5 of 29 non-acute asthmatic patients, and 2 of 59 nonasthmatic controls. In addition, absolute eosinophil counts, eNO, and total IgE were significantly elevated among the asthmatic patients. Sinus symptoms reported by questionnaire did not predict sinus CT findings. Among the patients with VCD, none had extensive sinus disease. They also had normal eNO, low IgE, and normal eosinophil count. Five of the patients presenting to the emergency room who were identified as acute asthmatic were identified with VCD by laryngoscopy and were all characterized by the absence of significant inflammation on their sinus CT scan, low IgE, and normal eosinophil count. CONCLUSIONS: Among patients presenting with intermittent or reversible airway obstruction, patients with VCD can be distinguished from asthma by minimum or absence of inflammation in their sinuses as shown by CT scan. Clinical symptom scores are not predictive of presence or extent of sinus disease in most cases.
BACKGROUND: The inappropriate closure of the vocal cords is characteristic of vocal cord dysfunction (VCD). These patients present with wheezing and frequently receive a misdiagnosis of asthma. OBJECTIVE: To demonstrate the ability of computed tomography (CT) scored for the presence and extent of sinus disease and markers of inflammation to distinguish patients with VCD from patients with asthma. METHODS: Comparisons of 13 patients with VCD were made to 77 patients presenting to the emergency room with acute asthma, 31 non-acute asthmatic patients, and 65 nonasthmatic controls. Evaluation consisted of exhaled nitric oxide gas (eNO), circulating eosinophils, and total serum immunoglobulin (Ig)E, as well as the sinus CT scan. RESULTS: Extensive sinus CT changes were present in 23 of 74 acute asthmatic patients, 5 of 29 non-acute asthmatic patients, and 2 of 59 nonasthmatic controls. In addition, absolute eosinophil counts, eNO, and total IgE were significantly elevated among the asthmatic patients. Sinus symptoms reported by questionnaire did not predict sinus CT findings. Among the patients with VCD, none had extensive sinus disease. They also had normal eNO, low IgE, and normal eosinophil count. Five of the patients presenting to the emergency room who were identified as acute asthmatic were identified with VCD by laryngoscopy and were all characterized by the absence of significant inflammation on their sinus CT scan, low IgE, and normal eosinophil count. CONCLUSIONS: Among patients presenting with intermittent or reversible airway obstruction, patients with VCD can be distinguished from asthma by minimum or absence of inflammation in their sinuses as shown by CT scan. Clinical symptom scores are not predictive of presence or extent of sinus disease in most cases.
Authors: Anneke ten Brinke; Diana C Grootendorst; Judith Th Schmidt; Francisca T De Bruïne; Mark A van Buchem; Peter J Sterk; Klaus F Rabe; Elisabeth H Bel Journal: J Allergy Clin Immunol Date: 2002-04 Impact factor: 10.793
Authors: P Demoly; L Crampette; M Mondain; A M Campbell; N Lequeux; I Enander; L B Schwartz; B Guerrier; F B Michel; J Bousquet Journal: J Allergy Clin Immunol Date: 1994-07 Impact factor: 10.793
Authors: P W Orobello; R I Park; L J Belcher; P Eggleston; H M Lederman; J R Banks; J F Modlin; R M Naclerio Journal: Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg Date: 1991-09
Authors: Yun M Shim; Autumn Burnette; Sean Lucas; Richard C Herring; Judith Weltman; James T Patrie; Arthur L Weltman; Thomas A Platts-Mills Journal: PLoS One Date: 2013-04-23 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Hege Havstad Clemm; J Tod Olin; Cameron McIntosh; Martin Schwellnus; Nicola Sewry; James H Hull; Thomas Halvorsen Journal: Br J Sports Med Date: 2022-02-22 Impact factor: 18.473