Why does a cleavage plane develop parallel to the spindle axis in conical sand dollar eggs? A key question for clarifying the mechanism of contractile ring positioning.

Three types of models have been proposed about how the mitotic apparatus determines the position of the cleavage furrow in animal cells. In the first and second types, the contractile ring appears in a cortical region that least and most astral microtubules reach, respectively. The third type is that the spindle midzone positions the contractile ring. In the previous study, a new model was proposed through analyses of cytokinesis in sand dollar and sea urchin eggs. Gradients of the surface density of microtubule plus ends are assumed to drive membrane proteins whose accumulation causes the formation of contractile-ring microfilaments. In the present study, the validity of each model is examined by simulating the furrow formation in conical sand dollar eggs with the mitotic apparatus oriented perpendicular to the cone axis. The new model predicts that unilateral furrows with cleavage planes roughly parallel to the spindle axis appear between the mitotic apparatus and the vertex besides the normally positioned furrow. The predictions are consistent with the observations by Rappaport & Rappaport (1994, Dev. Biol.164, 258-266). The other three types of models do not predict the formation of the ectopic furrows. Furthermore, it is pointed out that only the new model has the ability to explain the geometrical relationship between the mitotic apparatus and the contractile ring under various experimental conditions. These results strongly suggest the real existence of the membrane proteins postulated in the model.