STUDY OBJECTIVE: to determine whether melatonin will improve quality of sleep in healthy older people with age-related sleep maintenance problems. DESIGN: a double blind randomised placebo controlled crossover trial in healthy older volunteers. SETTING: a largely urban population, Auckland, New Zealand. PARTICIPANTS: participants were part of the larger Possible Role of Melatonin in Sleep of Elders study. People 65 years or more of age were recruited through widespread advertising. We screened 414 potential participants by mail using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, and selected 194 for clinic interview. Exclusions included depression, cognitive impairment, hypnosedative medications, sleep phase abnormalities, medical and/or environmental problems that might impair sleep. Twenty normal and 20 problem sleepers were randomly allocated for this study from a larger sample of 60 normal and 60 problem sleepers. MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS:24-hour urine 6-sulphatoxymelatonin was measured to estimate melatonin secretion in each participant. Five milligrams of melatonin, or matching placebo were each taken at bedtime for 4 weeks, separated by a 4-week washout period. Sleep quality was measured using sleep diaries, the Leeds Sleep Evaluation Questionnaire, and actigraphy. There was a significant difference between the groups in self-reported sleep quality indicators at entry, but no difference in melatonin secretion. Melatonin did not significantly improve any sleep parameter measured in either group. CONCLUSION: 5 mg of fast release melatonin taken at bedtime does not improve the quality of sleep in older people with age-related sleep maintenance problems.
RCT Entities:
STUDY OBJECTIVE: to determine whether melatonin will improve quality of sleep in healthy older people with age-related sleep maintenance problems. DESIGN: a double blind randomised placebo controlled crossover trial in healthy older volunteers. SETTING: a largely urban population, Auckland, New Zealand. PARTICIPANTS: participants were part of the larger Possible Role of Melatonin in Sleep of Elders study. People 65 years or more of age were recruited through widespread advertising. We screened 414 potential participants by mail using the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, and selected 194 for clinic interview. Exclusions included depression, cognitive impairment, hypnosedative medications, sleep phase abnormalities, medical and/or environmental problems that might impair sleep. Twenty normal and 20 problem sleepers were randomly allocated for this study from a larger sample of 60 normal and 60 problem sleepers. MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS: 24-hour urine 6-sulphatoxymelatonin was measured to estimate melatonin secretion in each participant. Five milligrams of melatonin, or matching placebo were each taken at bedtime for 4 weeks, separated by a 4-week washout period. Sleep quality was measured using sleep diaries, the Leeds Sleep Evaluation Questionnaire, and actigraphy. There was a significant difference between the groups in self-reported sleep quality indicators at entry, but no difference in melatonin secretion. Melatonin did not significantly improve any sleep parameter measured in either group. CONCLUSION: 5 mg of fast release melatonin taken at bedtime does not improve the quality of sleep in older people with age-related sleep maintenance problems.
Authors: Shawn D Youngstedt; Eric E Goff; Alexandria M Reynolds; Daniel F Kripke; Michael R Irwin; Richard R Bootzin; Nidha Khan; Girardin Jean-Louis Journal: Sleep Med Rev Date: 2015-08-28 Impact factor: 11.609
Authors: Nalaka S Gooneratne; Alena Y Z Edwards; Chen Zhou; Norma Cuellar; Michael A Grandner; Jeffrey S Barrett Journal: J Pineal Res Date: 2012-02-21 Impact factor: 13.007
Authors: Nina Buscemi; Ben Vandermeer; Nicola Hooton; Rena Pandya; Lisa Tjosvold; Lisa Hartling; Glen Baker; Terry P Klassen; Sunita Vohra Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2005-12 Impact factor: 5.128