Homo- and heterochiral alkylzinc fencholates: linear or nonlinear effects in dialkylzinc additions to benzaldehyde.

Scalemic mixtures of chiral anisyl fenchols with different ortho-substituents (X) in the anisyl moieties [X = H (1), Me (2), SiMe3 (3) and tBu (4)] are employed as pre-catalysts in enantioselective additions of diethylzinc to benzaldehyde. While a remarkable asymmetric depletion is apparent for X = H and Me, a linear relationship between the enantiomeric purity of the chiral source and the product 1-phenylpropanol is observed for X = SiMe3 and tBu. X-ray single crystal analyses show that racemic methylzinc fencholates obtained from 1 (X = H) and 2 (X = Me) yield homochiral dimeric complexes, while for 3 (X = SiMe3) and 4 (X = tBu) the heterochiral dimeric alkylzinc structures are formed. The enantiopure fenchols 1-4 all yield homochiral dimeric methylzinc complexes. Computed relative energies of homo- and heterochiral fencholate dimers with X = H and Me reveal an intrinsic preference for the formation of the homochiral dimers, consistent with the observed negative NLE. In contrast, similar stabilities are computed for homo- and heterochiral complexes of ligands 3 (X = SiMe3) and 4 (X = tBu), in agreement with the absence of a nonlinear effect for bulky ortho-subsituents.