S Struthers1, J Scanlon, K Parker, J Goddard, R Hallett. 1. Department of Paediatrics, Royal Hampshire County Hospital, Romsey Road, Winchester, Hampshire SO22 5DG, UK. simonstruthers@hotmail.com
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Parents often report that young children have "smelly urine" or a particular urinary odour. There is little evidence that these observations are relevant to the diagnosis of urinary tract infection (UTI). AIMS: To determine whether parental reporting of smelly urine is of any relevance to the diagnosis of UTI in children less than 6 years of age. METHODS: Parents whose children were having urine collected as part of their admission to a large district hospital were given a simple questionnaire to complete regarding the current smell of their child's urine. Parents were asked whether their child's urine smelled different from usual or had a particular smell. Microscopy and culture results of the child's urine were compared to their parent's questionnaire answers to see if there was a association between parental reporting of a different or particular urine smell and a diagnosis of UTI. RESULTS: One hundred and ten questionnaires and urine samples were obtained. Fifty two per cent of parents thought that their child's urine smelled different from usual or had a particular smell. Only 6.4% of children were diagnosed as having a UTI. There was no statistically significant association between parental reporting of abnormal urine smell and diagnosis of UTI. CONCLUSION: In determining whether a young child has a UTI, asking parents about urine smell is unlikely to be of benefit.
BACKGROUND: Parents often report that young children have "smelly urine" or a particular urinary odour. There is little evidence that these observations are relevant to the diagnosis of urinary tract infection (UTI). AIMS: To determine whether parental reporting of smelly urine is of any relevance to the diagnosis of UTI in children less than 6 years of age. METHODS: Parents whose children were having urine collected as part of their admission to a large district hospital were given a simple questionnaire to complete regarding the current smell of their child's urine. Parents were asked whether their child's urine smelled different from usual or had a particular smell. Microscopy and culture results of the child's urine were compared to their parent's questionnaire answers to see if there was a association between parental reporting of a different or particular urine smell and a diagnosis of UTI. RESULTS: One hundred and ten questionnaires and urine samples were obtained. Fifty two per cent of parents thought that their child's urine smelled different from usual or had a particular smell. Only 6.4% of children were diagnosed as having a UTI. There was no statistically significant association between parental reporting of abnormal urine smell and diagnosis of UTI. CONCLUSION: In determining whether a young child has a UTI, asking parents about urine smell is unlikely to be of benefit.
Authors: Alastair D Hay; Jonathan A C Sterne; Kerenza Hood; Paul Little; Brendan Delaney; William Hollingworth; Mandy Wootton; Robin Howe; Alasdair MacGowan; Michael Lawton; John Busby; Timothy Pickles; Kate Birnie; Kathryn O'Brien; Cherry-Ann Waldron; Jan Dudley; Judith Van Der Voort; Harriet Downing; Emma Thomas-Jones; Kim Harman; Catherine Lisles; Kate Rumsby; Stevo Durbaba; Penny Whiting; Christopher C Butler Journal: Ann Fam Med Date: 2016-07 Impact factor: 5.166
Authors: Megan O Schimpf; Michele Murdza; David M O'Sullivan; Paul K Tulikangas; Christine A LaSala Journal: Int Urogynecol J Pelvic Floor Dysfunct Date: 2007-03-14
Authors: Eva H Visser; Daan J C Berkhout; Jiwanjot Singh; Annemieke Vermeulen; Niloufar Ashtiani; Nanne K de Boer; Joanna A E van Wijk; Tim G de Meij; Arend Bökenkamp Journal: Biosensors (Basel) Date: 2020-05-05