Margaret Moss1, David Freed. 1. Nutrition and Allergy Clinic, 11 Mauldeth Close, Heaton Mersey, Cheshire SK4 3NP, Stockport, UK. mmoss.nutrition@ukonline.co.uk
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Certified death rates from coronary heart disease (CHD) are positively correlated country-by-country with milk consumption, particularly with that of the non-fat portion of milk. CHD death is also associated with circulating antibodies against milk fat-globule membrane (MFGM), raising the possibility that milk intake might be a specific risk factor for CHD. We studied the epidemiology and immunology of milk to see if the association is causal. METHODS: We plotted the intake of various foods country-by-country against CHD death rates to see if they were correlated in space and/or in time. We prepared fluorescein-tagged human antibodies against bovine MFGM to see if they showed any auto-reactivity against human tissue. RESULTS: Milk showed a positive correlation with CHD death rates in both space and time (r>0.9 in some cases). Beef was not correlated and cheese was negatively correlated, though not strongly. Wine was strongly negatively correlated. Human anti-bovine MFGM antibodies bind to human large granular lymphocytes and also to human platelets, causing aggregation. CONCLUSIONS: We suggest that non-fat aspects of milk, particularly the Ca/Mg ratio, lactose and MFGM antigens, have specific coronary atherogenic effects, both biochemical and immunological, and the simultaneous attack from these three directions may explain why this foodstuff has such a strong effect. Wine appears to be an antidote for the harmful effects of milk.
BACKGROUND: Certified death rates from coronary heart disease (CHD) are positively correlated country-by-country with milk consumption, particularly with that of the non-fat portion of milk. CHD death is also associated with circulating antibodies against milk fat-globule membrane (MFGM), raising the possibility that milk intake might be a specific risk factor for CHD. We studied the epidemiology and immunology of milk to see if the association is causal. METHODS: We plotted the intake of various foods country-by-country against CHD death rates to see if they were correlated in space and/or in time. We prepared fluorescein-tagged human antibodies against bovineMFGM to see if they showed any auto-reactivity against human tissue. RESULTS: Milk showed a positive correlation with CHD death rates in both space and time (r>0.9 in some cases). Beef was not correlated and cheese was negatively correlated, though not strongly. Wine was strongly negatively correlated. Human anti-bovineMFGM antibodies bind to human large granular lymphocytes and also to human platelets, causing aggregation. CONCLUSIONS: We suggest that non-fat aspects of milk, particularly the Ca/Mg ratio, lactose and MFGM antigens, have specific coronary atherogenic effects, both biochemical and immunological, and the simultaneous attack from these three directions may explain why this foodstuff has such a strong effect. Wine appears to be an antidote for the harmful effects of milk.
Authors: P C Elwood; J J Strain; Paula J Robson; Ann M Fehily; Janie Hughes; Janet Pickering; Andy Ness Journal: J Epidemiol Community Health Date: 2005-06 Impact factor: 3.710
Authors: Marieke A van Aerde; Sabita S Soedamah-Muthu; Johanna M Geleijnse; Marieke B Snijder; Giel Nijpels; Coen D A Stehouwer; Jacqueline M Dekker Journal: Eur J Nutr Date: 2012-05-05 Impact factor: 5.614
Authors: Hyuk Tae Kwon; Cheol Min Lee; Jin Ho Park; Jeong A Ko; Eun Ju Seong; Min Sun Park; BeLong Cho Journal: J Korean Med Sci Date: 2010-09-17 Impact factor: 2.153
Authors: J Bruce German; Robert A Gibson; Ronald M Krauss; Paul Nestel; Benoît Lamarche; Wija A van Staveren; Jan M Steijns; Lisette C P G M de Groot; Adam L Lock; Frédéric Destaillats Journal: Eur J Nutr Date: 2009-03-04 Impact factor: 5.614