Aberrant development of Plasmodium falciparum in hemoglobin CC red cells: implications for the malaria protective effect of the homozygous state.

Although selection of hemoglobin C (HbC) by malaria has been speculated for decades, only recently have epidemiologic studies provided support for HbC protection against malaria in West Africa. A reduced risk of malaria associated with the homozygous CC state has been attributed to the inability of CC cells to support parasite multiplication in vitro. However, there have been conflicting data and conclusions regarding the ability of CC red cells to support parasite replication. Reports that parasites cannot multiply in CC cells in vitro contrast with detection of substantial parasite densities in CC patients with malaria. We have therefore investigated Plasmodium falciparum growth in CC cells in vitro. Our data show that the multiplication rate of several P falciparum lines is measurable in CC cells, but lower than that in AA (HbA-normal) cells. A high proportion of ring forms and trophozoites disintegrates within a subset of CC cells, an observation that accounts for the overall lower replication rate. In addition, knobs present on the surface of infected CC cells are fewer in number and morphologically aberrant when compared with those on AA cells. Events in malaria pathogenesis that involve remodeling of the erythrocyte surface and the display of parasite antigens may be affected by these knob abnormalities. Our data suggest that only a subset of CC cells supports normal parasite replication and that components of malaria protection associated with the CC state may affect the parasite's replication capacity and involve aberrant knob formation on CC cells.