L Liew1, A Daudia, A A Narula. 1. Department of Otorhinolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Leicester Royal Infirmary, Leicester LE1 5WW, UK. lennyliew@ukgateway.net
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Tympanostomy tubes are associated with many complications, the most common being recurrent otorrhoea, in many cases resistant to medical treatment. With the associated vestibulo-cochlear toxicity of many topical antibiotics, their use is dose limited. Removal of the tympanostomy tube has been shown to cure the otorrhoea, however, it is associated with a high persistent perforation rate of 10-28%. A synchronous fat plug myringoplasty was performed with tube removal in an attempt to reduce the residual perforation rate. METHODS: A retrospective study of 13 consecutive children, nine male and four female, mean age 9.1 years (median=9, range 2-15), with a total of 15 ears (left=6, right=9) had either Shah Tubes (n=5), Shepard Tubes (n=1) or Shah Long Term Tubes (n=9) in-situ for middle ear effusions. The tubes were removed for recurrent otorrhoea. The tubes had been in-situ for a mean of 38.8 months (median=31, range 9-84 months). All ears had recurrent infections, with a variable response to topical antibiotics. All were under the care of one specialist, who performed all the procedures. At the time of tube removal, a standard fat graft myringoplasty was done. RESULTS: The procedure was successful in 15 of the 15 ears, and all perforations had closed by 3 weeks. Pure tone audiometry improved in 11 ears, remained the same in two and worsened in two (0-10 and 11-15 dBA, respectively). There were no complications arising from the procedure. Mean follow up was 13.7 months (median=9, range 3-31). None of the patients have re-perforated, but two have required re-ventilation of their middle ear for middle effusions, and one of these two has also undergone subsequent adeno-tonsillectomy. CONCLUSIONS: Our experience in this small series shows that the removal of a tympanostomy tube for recurrent otorrhoea can be successfully managed with a fat plug myringoplasty, with the benefit of a reduction in the persistent perforation rate following tympanostomy tube removal. It is a simple technique that requires little extra operating time with no significant morbidity.
OBJECTIVE: Tympanostomy tubes are associated with many complications, the most common being recurrent otorrhoea, in many cases resistant to medical treatment. With the associated vestibulo-cochlear toxicity of many topical antibiotics, their use is dose limited. Removal of the tympanostomy tube has been shown to cure the otorrhoea, however, it is associated with a high persistent perforation rate of 10-28%. A synchronous fat plug myringoplasty was performed with tube removal in an attempt to reduce the residual perforation rate. METHODS: A retrospective study of 13 consecutive children, nine male and four female, mean age 9.1 years (median=9, range 2-15), with a total of 15 ears (left=6, right=9) had either Shah Tubes (n=5), Shepard Tubes (n=1) or Shah Long Term Tubes (n=9) in-situ for middle ear effusions. The tubes were removed for recurrent otorrhoea. The tubes had been in-situ for a mean of 38.8 months (median=31, range 9-84 months). All ears had recurrent infections, with a variable response to topical antibiotics. All were under the care of one specialist, who performed all the procedures. At the time of tube removal, a standard fat graft myringoplasty was done. RESULTS: The procedure was successful in 15 of the 15 ears, and all perforations had closed by 3 weeks. Pure tone audiometry improved in 11 ears, remained the same in two and worsened in two (0-10 and 11-15 dBA, respectively). There were no complications arising from the procedure. Mean follow up was 13.7 months (median=9, range 3-31). None of the patients have re-perforated, but two have required re-ventilation of their middle ear for middle effusions, and one of these two has also undergone subsequent adeno-tonsillectomy. CONCLUSIONS: Our experience in this small series shows that the removal of a tympanostomy tube for recurrent otorrhoea can be successfully managed with a fat plug myringoplasty, with the benefit of a reduction in the persistent perforation rate following tympanostomy tube removal. It is a simple technique that requires little extra operating time with no significant morbidity.