L Strömberg1. 1. Department of Pediatrics, Vrinnevi Hospital, Norrköping, Sweden. leif.stromberg@lio.se
Abstract
AIM: To evaluate the diagnostic value of the skin-prick test and the atopy patch test in diagnosing basic food allergy in young children suffering from atopic eczema/dermatitis syndrome. METHODS: 141 children, the majority under 2 y of age (mean 16 mo) with atopic eczema/dermatitis syndrome were investigated using skin-prick and atopy patch tests for milk, egg, wheat and rye. Open diagnostic elimination challenge was done since this has been reported to be a reliable method in young children. RESULTS: A positive challenge response was found to milk in 63 (45%), egg in 78 (55%), wheat in 61 (43%) and rye in 61 (43%). Sensitivity/specificity of the atopy patch test was 60%/97% for milk, 71%/97% for egg, 90%/94% for wheat and 93%/90% for rye. For the skin-prick test the corresponding figures were 41%/99%, 60%/97%, 13%/98% and 15%/99%. CONCLUSION: Patch testing was found to be a more sensitive method than the skin-prick test in diagnosing food allergy in children with atopic eczema/dermatitis syndrome, especially in those under 2 y of age. Many children with a negative skin-prick test result have a positive patch test result, especially in the case of cereals. A diagnosis of food allergy should be confirmed by elimination and in the research setting also by challenge.
AIM: To evaluate the diagnostic value of the skin-prick test and the atopy patch test in diagnosing basic food allergy in young children suffering from atopic eczema/dermatitis syndrome. METHODS: 141 children, the majority under 2 y of age (mean 16 mo) with atopic eczema/dermatitis syndrome were investigated using skin-prick and atopy patch tests for milk, egg, wheat and rye. Open diagnostic elimination challenge was done since this has been reported to be a reliable method in young children. RESULTS: A positive challenge response was found to milk in 63 (45%), egg in 78 (55%), wheat in 61 (43%) and rye in 61 (43%). Sensitivity/specificity of the atopy patch test was 60%/97% for milk, 71%/97% for egg, 90%/94% for wheat and 93%/90% for rye. For the skin-prick test the corresponding figures were 41%/99%, 60%/97%, 13%/98% and 15%/99%. CONCLUSION: Patch testing was found to be a more sensitive method than the skin-prick test in diagnosing food allergy in children with atopic eczema/dermatitis syndrome, especially in those under 2 y of age. Many children with a negative skin-prick test result have a positive patch test result, especially in the case of cereals. A diagnosis of food allergy should be confirmed by elimination and in the research setting also by challenge.
Authors: Alessandro Fiocchi; Jan Brozek; Holger Schünemann; Sami L Bahna; Andrea von Berg; Kirsten Beyer; Martin Bozzola; Julia Bradsher; Enrico Compalati; Motohiro Ebisawa; Maria Antonieta Guzman; Haiqi Li; Ralf G Heine; Paul Keith; Gideon Lack; Massimo Landi; Alberto Martelli; Fabienne Rancé; Hugh Sampson; Airton Stein; Luigi Terracciano; Stefan Vieths Journal: World Allergy Organ J Date: 2010-04-23 Impact factor: 4.084