Manuel Girón1, Begoña Beviá, Elisa Medina, Manuel Simón Talero. 1. Departamento de Medicina Clínica, Universidad Miguel Hernández, (Campus de Sant Joan), Crtra. de Valencia Km 87, 03550 San Juan de Alicante. giron@icali.es
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The relationship between the quality of the physician-patient relationship and the outcomes of the clinical encounters in primary care are examined. METHOD: Focus groups of physicians and patients. A total of 24 professionals and 22 patients took part. RESULTS: The physicians perceived a relationship to exist between the scarcity of healthcare resources (short length of time with each patient, care-providing overload, lack of specific resources, lack of training), conflicts with "difficult" patients and the influence of the psychosocial factors in the clinical encounter and error, burnout, defensive medicine and the low quality of the services. Communication/examination-related problems during the clinical interview and by negative feelings acted as intermediary factors in this relationship. The patients perceived a relationship to exist between an operating pattern characterized by short office visits scheduled at an overloaded pace and physician, patient communications problems and error and conflict in the clinical encounter. There is also a relationship between the physician's humanist attitude and a better outcome of the health problems. The objectives and priorities of the health care system, out of touch with the needs of the community, are seen as being key determining factors as regards the lacks considered to exist. CONCLUSIONS: The physician-patient relationship processes play a mediating role between the health care resources and the outcomes of the clinical encounters. Improving the care provided and the physician-patient relationship in primary care requires a multi-dimensional approach and view which goes beyond the measures taken regarding individual physician and patient-related factors.
BACKGROUND: The relationship between the quality of the physician-patient relationship and the outcomes of the clinical encounters in primary care are examined. METHOD: Focus groups of physicians and patients. A total of 24 professionals and 22 patients took part. RESULTS: The physicians perceived a relationship to exist between the scarcity of healthcare resources (short length of time with each patient, care-providing overload, lack of specific resources, lack of training), conflicts with "difficult" patients and the influence of the psychosocial factors in the clinical encounter and error, burnout, defensive medicine and the low quality of the services. Communication/examination-related problems during the clinical interview and by negative feelings acted as intermediary factors in this relationship. The patients perceived a relationship to exist between an operating pattern characterized by short office visits scheduled at an overloaded pace and physician, patient communications problems and error and conflict in the clinical encounter. There is also a relationship between the physician's humanist attitude and a better outcome of the health problems. The objectives and priorities of the health care system, out of touch with the needs of the community, are seen as being key determining factors as regards the lacks considered to exist. CONCLUSIONS: The physician-patient relationship processes play a mediating role between the health care resources and the outcomes of the clinical encounters. Improving the care provided and the physician-patient relationship in primary care requires a multi-dimensional approach and view which goes beyond the measures taken regarding individual physician and patient-related factors.
Authors: Jesus Montero-Marin; Carlos Collado-Navarro; Mayte Navarro-Gil; Alba Lopez-Montoyo; Marcelo Demarzo; Paola Herrera-Mercadal; Alberto Barcelo-Soler; Javier Garcia-Campayo Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2019-10-08 Impact factor: 2.692
Authors: Mikel Baza Bueno; Elena Serrano Ferrández; Ana Dosio Revenga; Nabil Diouri; M José Fernández de Sanmamed Santos; Carlos Calderón Gómez Journal: Aten Primaria Date: 2019-04-25 Impact factor: 1.137
Authors: Jesus Montero-Marin; Fernando Zubiaga; Maria Cereceda; Marcelo Marcos Piva Demarzo; Patricia Trenc; Javier Garcia-Campayo Journal: PLoS One Date: 2016-06-16 Impact factor: 3.240