The combination of HSV-tk and endostatin gene therapy eradicates orthotopic human renal cell carcinomas in nude mice.

BACKGROUND AND METHODS: Gene therapy may offer a new tool for the treatment of renal cell carcinoma (RCC). We have tested a combination of cytotoxic and antiangiogenic gene therapy for wild-type orthotopic human RCC xenografts in nude mice using intratumoral adenovirus-mediated herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) and endostatin (ES) gene therapy. In vivo magnetic resonance imaging, morphometry, immunocytochemistry, and survival were used to evaluate the treatment effect. Adenovirus-mediated marker gene transfers (GFP) were used as controls.
RESULTS: In vivo transduction efficiency, measured using GFP gene transfer, was 27+/-7%. The combination gene therapy with HSV-tk and ES adenoviruses resulted in a significant antitumor effect (P<.01) compared to single HSV-tk (n.s.) or ES (n.s.). In the survival study, all tumors with single gene therapy using HSV-tk, ES, and marker gene adenoviruses showed progression in magnetic resonance imaging. In contrast, the majority of the tumors in the combination treatment group remained dormant or were eradicated (57%). Survival of these mice equaled healthy nude mice, and was significantly prolonged (P<.0001) compared to HSV-tk (P<.028) and ES (n.s.) groups.
CONCLUSIONS: It is concluded that the inhibition of angiogenesis using ES gene transfer together with the cytotoxic HSV-tk gene therapy results in a significantly improved treatment effect in RCC compared to the single gene treatments.