Literature DB >> 12356957

Is posthumous semen retrieval ethically permissible?

R D Orr1, M Siegler.   

Abstract

It is possible to retrieve viable sperm from a dying man or from a recently dead body. This sperm can be frozen for later use by his wife or partner to produce his genetic offspring. But the technical feasibility alone does not morally justify such an endeavour. Posthumous semen retrieval raises questions about consent, the respectful treatment of the dead body, and the welfare of the child to be. We present two cases, discuss these three issues, and conclude that such requests should generally not be honoured unless there is convincing evidence that the dead man would want his widow to carry and bear his child. Even with consent, the welfare of the potential child must be considered.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Analytical Approach; Genetics and Reproduction

Mesh:

Year:  2002        PMID: 12356957      PMCID: PMC1733647          DOI: 10.1136/jme.28.5.299

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Med Ethics        ISSN: 0306-6800            Impact factor:   2.903


  13 in total

1.  Traditional concepts and nontraditional conceptions: social security survivor's benefits for posthumously conceived children.

Authors:  G J Banks
Journal:  Loyola Los Angel Law Rev       Date:  1999-01

2.  The case for presumed consent to transplant human organs after death.

Authors:  C Cohen
Journal:  Transplant Proc       Date:  1992-10       Impact factor: 1.066

3.  "An ignoble form of cannibalism": reflections on the Pittsburgh protocol for procuring organs from non-heart-beating cadavers.

Authors:  R C Fox
Journal:  Kennedy Inst Ethics J       Date:  1993-06

Review 4.  Japan's dilemma with the definition of death.

Authors:  R Kimura
Journal:  Kennedy Inst Ethics J       Date:  1991-06

5.  Reanimation: overcoming objections and obstacles to organ retrieval from non-heart-beating cadaver donors.

Authors:  R D Orr; S R Gundry; L L Bailey
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  1997-02       Impact factor: 2.903

6.  Using newly deceased patients to teach resuscitation procedures.

Authors:  J P Burns; F E Reardon; R D Truog
Journal:  N Engl J Med       Date:  1994-12-15       Impact factor: 91.245

7.  Have we lost our senses? Problems with maintaining brain-dead bodies carrying fetuses.

Authors:  J E Frader
Journal:  J Clin Ethics       Date:  1993

8.  Law versus life: the ethical imperative to practice and teach using the newly dead emergency department patient.

Authors:  K V Iserson
Journal:  Ann Emerg Med       Date:  1995-01       Impact factor: 5.721

9.  Don't ask, don't tell: practicing minimally invasive resuscitation techniques on the newly dead.

Authors:  A D Goldblatt
Journal:  Ann Emerg Med       Date:  1995-01       Impact factor: 5.721

10.  A method for obtaining viable sperm in the postmortem state.

Authors:  C M Rothman
Journal:  Fertil Steril       Date:  1980-11       Impact factor: 7.329

View more
  6 in total

1.  Post-mortem Reproduction from a Vietnamese Perspective-an Analysis and Commentary.

Authors:  Hai Thanh Doan; Diep Thi Phuong Doan; Nguyen Kim The Duong
Journal:  Asian Bioeth Rev       Date:  2020-08-06

2.  Postmortem sperm retrieval for in vitro fertilization treatment: care to be taken - a Brazilian case report.

Authors:  Edilberto Araújo; Cássio L Fácio; Luís Antonio Velani; Rui N Barbosa; Ligiane A Machado-Paula; Lígia F Previato
Journal:  JBRA Assist Reprod       Date:  2014-09-27

Review 3.  Perimortem and postmortem sperm acquisition: review of clinical data.

Authors:  Stav Oved Ovics; Shira Baram; Simon Nothman; Amir Weiss; Ronit Beck-Fruchter
Journal:  J Assist Reprod Genet       Date:  2022-02-21       Impact factor: 3.357

4.  Response to Orr and Siegler--collective intentionality and procreative desires: the permissible view on consent to posthumous conception.

Authors:  M Parker
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2004-08       Impact factor: 2.903

5.  Contrasting selected reproductive challenges of today with those of antiquity--the past is prologue.

Authors:  Christopher A Jones; Eric Scott Sills
Journal:  Ulster Med J       Date:  2013-09

6.  A cross-cultural analysis of posthumous reproduction: The significance of the gender and margins-of-life perspectives.

Authors:  Yael Hashiloni-Dolev; Silke Schicktanz
Journal:  Reprod Biomed Soc Online       Date:  2017-04-29
  6 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.