Activation of complement pathways in xenotransplantation: an in vitro study.

Pig-to-human xenotransplantation faces the problem of hyperacute graft rejection due to the presence of human naturally occurring antibodies against the disaccharide Galalpha1-3Gal (anti-Gal antibodies) expressed on pig endothelium. Antibody-mediated complement activation is usually referred to as classical pathway activation. In this study we examined if the alternative complement pathway is also directly activated through anti-Gal antibodies or if the classical pathway is indispensable. We therefore developed a hemolysis test with rabbit erythrocytes (E), which have an activating surface for the alternative complement pathway and express abundant amounts of Galalpha1-3Gal, and used this assay in addition to the standard complement tests CH50 and AP50. In this rabbit E CH50 (RECH50) assay we were able to study activation of both major complement pathways simultaneously. FACS analysis was used to trace complement and antibody deposition on rabbit E. Anti-Gal depletion of human serum by immunoabsorption revealed a 65% reduction of rabbit E hemolysis in the RECH50 test (value before absorption: 28 +/- 5.8, after absorption: 9.9 +/- 2.8, P<0.001), but only a 35% reduction of lysis in the AP50 test (AP50 before 11.3 +/- 2.1, after 7.4 +/- 2.0, P<0.002). Repletion with purified anti-Gal fully restored hemolysis in both assays. Serum depleted of Clq showed a reduced lysis of rabbit E as compared to normal human serum; this effect increased with higher serum dilutions. The reciprocal picture, i.e. less effect on hemolysis with increasing dilution, was seen with factor D depleted serum. Comparison of the RECH50 values with the AP50 values revealed an 8.4-fold increase of lysis in the RECH50 test, in which both complement pathways are running. By FACS analysis, complement deposition on rabbit E was determined and components of the classical pathway were found, especially in sera where the alternative pathway was disrupted. We conclude that in our model anti-Gal induce lysis via both classical and alternative complement pathways, but that the alternative pathway activation is of minor importance. In addition, we saw that with higher serum dilutions, the classical pathway (i.e. anti-Gal-mediated lysis) takes a predominant role in lysing the rabbit E. As anti-Gal-mediated activation of the alternative complement cascade seems of minor importance based on our results, and as there are only few surfaces in transplanted organs that would favor the alternative pathway to be executed, the specific inhibition of early steps of the classical pathway appears as a realistic strategy in pig-to-primate xenotransplantation that-to the benefit of the patient-leaves the mainly anti-bacterial defense by the alternative pathway intact.