OBJECTIVE: Surgery is the treatment of reference for early-stage esophageal cancer, but 5-year survival is only 20% to 25%. After complete resection (R0), survival is significantly longer than after incomplete resection, with microscopic (R1) or macroscopic (R2) penetration. The purpose of this work was to identify retrospectively the factors predictive of complete resection of operable esophageal cancers. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between January 1982 and March 2001, 746 patients with esophageal cancer underwent curative surgery. R0 resection was performed in 585 patients (78.4%), R1 in 61 (8.2%) and R2 in 100 (13.4%). Univariate and multivariate analysis included 28 preoperative, clinical, tumor and therapeutic parameters. RESULTS: Multivariate analysis showed that factors predictive of complete resection R0 were: absence of any modification of the esophageal axis on the barium swallow (P=0.054), a partial or complete response to preoperative radio-chemotherapy (P=0.042), tumor height<10 cm (P=0.1) and tumor diameter<30 mm (P=0.01). Three groups of patients were identified from the 2 most significant variables. Group 1: no deviation of the axis on the barium swallow (n=501). Group 2: deviation of the axis on the barium swallow and partial or complete response to radiochemotherapy (n=91). Group 3: deviation of the axis on the barium swallow and no response to radiochemotherapy or no preoperative treatment (n=126). For the three groups, rate of R0 resection was 82.6%, 80.1% and 61.1% and 5-year actuarial survival 36%, 27% and 14%, respectively. These rates were significantly different between groups (P<10(- 4)) and two by two (P<0.04). CONCLUSION: Complete resection of esophageal cancer is predictable. After validation with an independent population the findings presented here could be used to establish stratification criteria for future therapeutic trials.
OBJECTIVE: Surgery is the treatment of reference for early-stage esophageal cancer, but 5-year survival is only 20% to 25%. After complete resection (R0), survival is significantly longer than after incomplete resection, with microscopic (R1) or macroscopic (R2) penetration. The purpose of this work was to identify retrospectively the factors predictive of complete resection of operable esophageal cancers. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between January 1982 and March 2001, 746 patients with esophageal cancer underwent curative surgery. R0 resection was performed in 585 patients (78.4%), R1 in 61 (8.2%) and R2 in 100 (13.4%). Univariate and multivariate analysis included 28 preoperative, clinical, tumor and therapeutic parameters. RESULTS: Multivariate analysis showed that factors predictive of complete resection R0 were: absence of any modification of the esophageal axis on the barium swallow (P=0.054), a partial or complete response to preoperative radio-chemotherapy (P=0.042), tumor height<10 cm (P=0.1) and tumor diameter<30 mm (P=0.01). Three groups of patients were identified from the 2 most significant variables. Group 1: no deviation of the axis on the barium swallow (n=501). Group 2: deviation of the axis on the barium swallow and partial or complete response to radiochemotherapy (n=91). Group 3: deviation of the axis on the barium swallow and no response to radiochemotherapy or no preoperative treatment (n=126). For the three groups, rate of R0 resection was 82.6%, 80.1% and 61.1% and 5-year actuarial survival 36%, 27% and 14%, respectively. These rates were significantly different between groups (P<10(- 4)) and two by two (P<0.04). CONCLUSION: Complete resection of esophageal cancer is predictable. After validation with an independent population the findings presented here could be used to establish stratification criteria for future therapeutic trials.
Authors: Do Hyoung Lim; Young-Hyuck Im; Sang Hoon Ji; Byeong-Bae Park; Mi Jung Oh; Jeeyun Lee; Keun Woo Park; Se-Hoon Lee; Joon-Oh Park; Kihyun Kim; Won Seog Kim; Chul Won Jung; Young Suk Park; Won Ki Kang; Mark H Lee; Kwanmien Kim; Young Mog Shim; Keunchil Park Journal: Cancer Res Treat Date: 2004-08-31 Impact factor: 4.679