BACKGROUND: In the present series of 170 patients who underwent extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy (SWL) treatment for ureteral stones, the authors determine which patients with ureteral stones had an unsuccessful outcome. METHODS: The records of 170 patients with ureteral stones who were treated with SWL using the Dornier lithotriptor U/50 (EMSE 140) between January 1998 and December 1999 were retrospectively investigated. One hundred and thirty-one patients were treated with SWL alone (single session, n = 98; multiple session, n = 33) and 39 patients required auxiliary treatment due to failure of SWL (33 with transurethral ureterolithotripsy (TUL), one with open lithotomy, and five with residual fragments who were followed up). These two groups were compared using multivariate logistic regression analysis. RESULTS: Lower ureteral stones and stones more than 12 mm in diameter were associated with a poor outcome of SWL. There were no significant differences in age, gender, number of stones, JJ stent placement, and degree of ureteral obstruction due to the stone between the two groups. The odds ratios of lower ureteral stones and stones > or = 12 mm were 4.18 and 2.57, respectively. CONCLUSION: Patients with distal ureteral stones and/or stones more than 12 mm in diameter were difficult to treat successfully with SWL. Alternatives such as TUL should possibly be considered as a first-line therapy for these stones.
BACKGROUND: In the present series of 170 patients who underwent extracorporeal shock-wave lithotripsy (SWL) treatment for ureteral stones, the authors determine which patients with ureteral stones had an unsuccessful outcome. METHODS: The records of 170 patients with ureteral stones who were treated with SWL using the Dornier lithotriptor U/50 (EMSE 140) between January 1998 and December 1999 were retrospectively investigated. One hundred and thirty-one patients were treated with SWL alone (single session, n = 98; multiple session, n = 33) and 39 patients required auxiliary treatment due to failure of SWL (33 with transurethral ureterolithotripsy (TUL), one with open lithotomy, and five with residual fragments who were followed up). These two groups were compared using multivariate logistic regression analysis. RESULTS: Lower ureteral stones and stones more than 12 mm in diameter were associated with a poor outcome of SWL. There were no significant differences in age, gender, number of stones, JJ stent placement, and degree of ureteral obstruction due to the stone between the two groups. The odds ratios of lower ureteral stones and stones > or = 12 mm were 4.18 and 2.57, respectively. CONCLUSION:Patients with distal ureteral stones and/or stones more than 12 mm in diameter were difficult to treat successfully with SWL. Alternatives such as TUL should possibly be considered as a first-line therapy for these stones.
Authors: Caroline Pettenati; Amine Benchikh El Fegoun; Vincent Hupertan; Sébastien Dominique; Vincent Ravery Journal: Cent European J Urol Date: 2013-11-18