OBJECTIVE: To confirm, using an observational cohort design, the relation between severely stressful life experiences and relapse of breast cancer found in a previous case-control study. DESIGN: Prospective follow up for five years of a cohort of women newly diagnosed as having breast cancer, collecting data on stressful life experiences, depression, and biological prognostic factors. SETTING: NHS breast clinic, London; 1991-9. PARTICIPANTS: A consecutive series of women aged under 60 newly diagnosed as having a primary operable breast tumour. 202/222 (91%) eligible women participated in the first life experiences interview. 170 (77%) provided complete interview data either up to 5 years after diagnosis or to recurrence. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Recurrence of disease. RESULTS: We controlled for biological prognostic factors (lymph node infiltration and tumour histology), and found no increased risk of recurrence in women who had had one or more severely stressful life experiences in the year before diagnosis compared with women who did not (hazard ratio 1.01, 95% confidence interval 0.58 to 1.74, P=0.99). Women who had had one or more severely stressful life experiences in the 5 years after diagnosis had a lower risk of recurrence (0.52, 0.29 to 0.95, P=0.03) than those who did not. CONCLUSION: These data do not confirm an earlier finding from a case-control study that severely stressful life experiences increase the risk of recurrence of breast cancer. Differences in case control and prospective methods may explain the contradictory results. We took the prospective study as the more robust, and the results suggest that women with breast cancer need not fear that stressful experiences will precipitate the return of their disease.
OBJECTIVE: To confirm, using an observational cohort design, the relation between severely stressful life experiences and relapse of breast cancer found in a previous case-control study. DESIGN: Prospective follow up for five years of a cohort of women newly diagnosed as having breast cancer, collecting data on stressful life experiences, depression, and biological prognostic factors. SETTING: NHS breast clinic, London; 1991-9. PARTICIPANTS: A consecutive series of women aged under 60 newly diagnosed as having a primary operable breast tumour. 202/222 (91%) eligible women participated in the first life experiences interview. 170 (77%) provided complete interview data either up to 5 years after diagnosis or to recurrence. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Recurrence of disease. RESULTS: We controlled for biological prognostic factors (lymph node infiltration and tumour histology), and found no increased risk of recurrence in women who had had one or more severely stressful life experiences in the year before diagnosis compared with women who did not (hazard ratio 1.01, 95% confidence interval 0.58 to 1.74, P=0.99). Women who had had one or more severely stressful life experiences in the 5 years after diagnosis had a lower risk of recurrence (0.52, 0.29 to 0.95, P=0.03) than those who did not. CONCLUSION: These data do not confirm an earlier finding from a case-control study that severely stressful life experiences increase the risk of recurrence of breast cancer. Differences in case control and prospective methods may explain the contradictory results. We took the prospective study as the more robust, and the results suggest that women with breast cancer need not fear that stressful experiences will precipitate the return of their disease.
Authors: R Peto; M C Pike; P Armitage; N E Breslow; D R Cox; S V Howard; N Mantel; K McPherson; J Peto; P G Smith Journal: Br J Cancer Date: 1977-01 Impact factor: 7.640
Authors: Oxana Palesh; Lisa D Butler; Cheryl Koopman; Janine Giese-Davis; Robert Carlson; David Spiegel Journal: J Psychosom Res Date: 2007-08-02 Impact factor: 3.006
Authors: Erica K Sloan; Saul J Priceman; Benjamin F Cox; Stephanie Yu; Matthew A Pimentel; Veera Tangkanangnukul; Jesusa M G Arevalo; Kouki Morizono; Breanne D W Karanikolas; Lily Wu; Anil K Sood; Steven W Cole Journal: Cancer Res Date: 2010-09-07 Impact factor: 12.701
Authors: Jayant Agarwal; Karen Powers; Lisa Pappas; Luke Buchmann; Layla Anderson; Lisa Gauchay; Anne Rich Journal: Support Care Cancer Date: 2013-03-06 Impact factor: 3.603
Authors: M H Olsen; P E Bidstrup; K Frederiksen; N H Rod; M Grønbaek; S O Dalton; C Johansen Journal: Br J Cancer Date: 2012-03-20 Impact factor: 7.640
Authors: J Preston Campbell; Matthew R Karolak; Yun Ma; Daniel S Perrien; S Kathryn Masood-Campbell; Niki L Penner; Steve A Munoz; Andries Zijlstra; Xiangli Yang; Julie A Sterling; Florent Elefteriou Journal: PLoS Biol Date: 2012-07-17 Impact factor: 8.029