David J Bearison1, Nadia Minian, Linda Granowetter. 1. The Graduate Center, City University of New York, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York, New York 10036, USA. dbearison@gc.cuny.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To describe beliefs about asthma and asthma treatment in a Hispanic (Dominican-American) community to determine how alternative belief systems affect compliance with medical regimens. METHOD: Twenty-five mothers of children with asthma were interviewed in their homes, in their primary language, Spanish. Mothers were questioned about their beliefs regarding asthma etiology, treatment, prevention of acute episodes, and use of prescribed medications. RESULTS: Most mothers (72%) said that they did not use prescribed medicines for the prevention of asthma; instead, they substituted folk remedies called "zumos." The home remedies were derived from their folk beliefs about health and illness. Most mothers (60%) thought that their child did not have asthma in the absence of an acute episode. Eighty-eight percent said that medications are overused in this country and that physicians hide therapeutic information from them. CONCLUSIONS: Mothers' reliance on home remedies for asthma prevention leads to a high rate of noncompliance with prescribed regimens. Yet they perceive themselves as compliant with an effective regimen that differs from standard medical practice. Further studies should explore ways of promoting physician/patient communication in order to find ways of coordinating medical and folk beliefs to enhance compliance with medically prescribed regimens.
OBJECTIVE: To describe beliefs about asthma and asthma treatment in a Hispanic (Dominican-American) community to determine how alternative belief systems affect compliance with medical regimens. METHOD: Twenty-five mothers of children with asthma were interviewed in their homes, in their primary language, Spanish. Mothers were questioned about their beliefs regarding asthma etiology, treatment, prevention of acute episodes, and use of prescribed medications. RESULTS: Most mothers (72%) said that they did not use prescribed medicines for the prevention of asthma; instead, they substituted folk remedies called "zumos." The home remedies were derived from their folk beliefs about health and illness. Most mothers (60%) thought that their child did not have asthma in the absence of an acute episode. Eighty-eight percent said that medications are overused in this country and that physicians hide therapeutic information from them. CONCLUSIONS: Mothers' reliance on home remedies for asthma prevention leads to a high rate of noncompliance with prescribed regimens. Yet they perceive themselves as compliant with an effective regimen that differs from standard medical practice. Further studies should explore ways of promoting physician/patient communication in order to find ways of coordinating medical and folk beliefs to enhance compliance with medically prescribed regimens.
Authors: Daphne Koinis-Mitchell; Elizabeth L McQuaid; Ronald Seifer; Sheryl J Kopel; Cynthia Esteban; Glorisa Canino; Cynthia Garcia-Coll; Robert Klein; Gregory K Fritz Journal: J Pediatr Psychol Date: 2007-01-11
Authors: Michelle Trivedi; Vicki Fung; Elyse O Kharbanda; Emma K Larkin; Melissa G Butler; Kelly Horan; Tracy A Lieu; Ann Chen Wu Journal: J Asthma Date: 2017-07-14 Impact factor: 2.515
Authors: Elizabeth L McQuaid; David A Fedele; Sue K Adams; Daphne Koinis-Mitchell; Jessica Mitchell; Sheryl J Kopel; Ronald Seifer; Barbara Jandasek; Gregory K Fritz; Glorisa Canino Journal: Acad Pediatr Date: 2014 Mar-Apr Impact factor: 3.107
Authors: Luis Caraballo; Josefina Zakzuk; Bee Wah Lee; Nathalie Acevedo; Jian Yi Soh; Mario Sánchez-Borges; Elham Hossny; Elizabeth García; Nelson Rosario; Ignacio Ansotegui; Leonardo Puerta; Jorge Sánchez; Victoria Cardona Journal: World Allergy Organ J Date: 2016-06-27 Impact factor: 4.084
Authors: Glorisa Canino; Elizabeth L McQuaid; Maria Alvarez; Angel Colon; Cynthia Esteban; Vivian Febo; Robert B Klein; Daphne Koinis Mitchell; Sheryl J Kopel; Federico Montealegre; Alexander N Ortega; Jose Rodriguez-Santana; Ronald Seifer; Gregory K Fritz Journal: Pediatr Pulmonol Date: 2009-09
Authors: Elizabeth L McQuaid; Juan Vasquez; Glorisa Canino; Gregory K Fritz; Alexander N Ortega; Angel Colon; Robert B Klein; Sheryl J Kopel; Daphne Koinis-Mitchell; Cynthia A Esteban; Ronald Seifer Journal: Pediatr Pulmonol Date: 2009-09