Preneoplastic lesions of the lung.

Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer deaths worldwide. If we can define and detect preneoplastic lesions, we might have a chance of improving survival. The World Health Organization has defined three preneoplastic lesions of the bronchial epithelium: squamous dysplasia/carcinoma in situ; atypical adenomatous hyperplasia; and diffuse idiopathic pulmonary neuroendocrine cell hyperplasia. These lesions are believed to progress to squamous cell carcinoma, adenocarcinoma and carcinoid tumors, respectively. In this review we summarize the data supporting the preneoplastic nature of these lesions, and delve into some of the genetic changes found in atypical adenomatous hyperplasia and squamous dysplasia/carcinoma in situ.

Introduction

Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer deaths worldwide [1] and the number of cases continues to increase. Smoking is the primary cause in the great majority of these cases. In Asia, particularly China, smoking rates continue to increase. Despite advances in therapy, the overall survival rate for lung cancer patients remains only 15%. This poor survival is probably due to the relatively advanced stage of disease at diagnosis. To date, screening trials have had no significant impact on survival [2]. Screening can detect small (2–3 mm in size), asymptomatic nodules, but even these nodules may already be malignant, and therefore late in the course of the disease. Tumor cells have been found in the peripheral blood and bone marrow of patients with lung cancer of all sizes and stages [3,4].

If lung cancer could be identified earlier – at a preneoplastic stage, before angiogenesis, invasion and micrometastases can occur – we might have a greater chance of improving survival. At this point, we have little information about possible progenitor lesions. Which lesions are preneoplastic? How and why do they progress? Is there any treatment that can prevent progression? Advances in molecular biology and microdissection techniques, and greater understanding of genetic changes involved in malignant transformation will aid in answering some of these questions. Advances in computerized tomography (CT), bronchoscopy and genomics technology raise the possibility that we may be able to detect these early lesions in vivo. Therefore, if preneoplastic lesions can be defined, and if appropriate therapies can be found, screening may then significantly improve survival.

To define preneoplastic lesions, we need to understand the molecular events that occur during bronchogenic carcinogenesis. Carcinogenesis is thought to be a multistep process consisting of the accumulation of gene mutations. Preneoplastic lesions may be morphological phenotypes of the different steps in this progression from normal to malignant tissue. We are just beginning to identify the presumed preneoplastic lesions in the bronchial epithelium.

The World Health Organization (WHO) recently published a tumor classification system that defines three different preneoplastic lesions of the bronchial epithelium: squamous dysplasia (SD) and carcinoma in situ (CIS), which may be precursors to squamous cell carcinoma; atypical adenomatous hyperplasia (AAH), which may be the progenitor lesion for adenocarcinoma (particularly peripheral); and diffuse idiopathic pulmonary neuroendocrine cell hyperplasia (DIP-NECH), which may progress to carcinoid [5,6]. Additional possible preneoplastic lesions and conditions include: basal cell hyperplasia and squamous metaplasia (progressing to SD and CIS); adenomatous hyperplasia (progressing to AAH); angiogenic squamous dysplasia (consisting of microscopic projections into the bronchial lumen, surfaced by squamous dysplasia); and pulmonary fibrosis.

No preneoplastic lesion has been clearly identified for small cell carcinoma but, occasionally, SD/CIS can be seen in the adjacent airway mucosa. However, mucosa that appears normal but with significant genetic abnormalities is often found near small cell tumors, suggesting that these tumors might arise without going through a stage of morphologically recognizable preinvasive lesion [6].

In this review we will summarize the data supporting the classification of these various lesions as preneoplastic, and delve into some of the genetic changes found in AAH and SD/CIS (the most extensively studied of these lesions).

Preneoplastic lesions

The sequence of precursor lesions for squamous cell carcinoma may be hyperplasia-metaplasia-dysplasia-CIS. This progression of disease has long been recognized [7,8]. Basal cell hyperplasia is present when the basal cell layer is more than three cells thick, and SD is present when there is cytologic atypia. The WHO has classified SD and CIS as preneoplastic lesions. This classification also provides criteria for the distinction of mild, moderate, and severe dysplasia and CIS, based on the distribution of atypical cells and mitotic figures (Fig. 1). Several problems occur with this classification schema. The classification assumes that the lesions progress in an orderly manner, from hyperplasia to metaplasia, and then to increasing degrees of dysplasia, but this may not be the case. In addition, the grading of lesions is not uniform. Some investigators and clinicians use only two divisions – low grade versus high grade dysplasia. There is also some overlap between categories, and in any particular case a range of grades may be seen.

Figure 1

Normal bronchial mucosa, atypical adenomatous hyperplasia (AAH), squamous dysplasia and invasive squamous carcinoma have been stained for various markers. The first column shows hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) tissue staining. The picture of AAH shows low (40×) and high (400×, inset) power images. The H&E staining of squamous dysplasia shows relatively normal mucosa on the left of the image and severe dysplasia on the right. In severe dysplasia, there is considerable cellular pleiomorphism, coarse uneven chromatin, and little cell maturation. Vertical nuclei and mitotic figures are present in the lower two thirds of the mucosa. In invasive carcinoma the cytological aberration is extreme, mitoses occur at all levels of the mucosa, and maturation is absent. The second column shows staining for the proliferation marker, Ki-67, in the various lesions. Ki-67 is essentially negative in normal tissue. The images show increased Ki-67 in AAH, with a further increase in squamous dysplasia and carcinoma. In the third column, p53 is not observed in the normal bronchial mucosa or in AAH, but is increased in both squamous dysplasia and squamous carcinoma. In the fourth column, p21 (p53-inducible cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor) is increased only in squamous carcinoma, but not in AAH or normal bronchial mucosa.

The sequence of precursor lesions for some pulmonary adenocarcinomas may be adenomatous hyperplasia to AAH. Recently, there has been great interest in AAH as the precursor for peripheral parenchymal adenocarcinoma, just as colon adenomas are the precursors for colon adenocarcinomas [9]. Lesions in AAH are usually small, asymptomatic, radiologically invisible, incidental microscopic findings in surgically resected lung. Larger lesions may be grossly visible on the cut surface of the lung, or as ground glass lesions on a chest CT. Cuboidal or low columnar cells, with the morphology of type 2 pneumocytes or Clara cells, line a group of alveoli, and are sometimes distributed around a terminal or respiratory bronchiole. Excess collagen and/or lymphocytes might cause alveolar wall thickening. Mitotic figures are unusual. Some lesions may have large amounts of scar tissue or a heavy lymphoid infiltrate (Fig. 1).

At an almost indistinguishable point, the more atypical AAH becomes a bronchoalveolar cell carcinoma (BAC) (in current WHO classification, a noninvasive tumor growing by replacement of alveolar lining cells). The largest and most atypical AAH and BAC may actually be the same thing [6]. Larger AAH lesions may even have foci of invasion. Some authors have therefore suggested using size (for example 5 mm) to distinguish between AAH and BAC. As in the squamous cell carcinoma sequence, other problems with the classification of AAH relate to reproducibility and uniformity, and lack of data about progression from hyperplasia to mild, and then severe, atypical hyperplasia

Other possible preneoplastic conditions

A precursor lesion for carcinoid tumors may be DIP-NECH, and some researchers have also suggested a possible relationship with other neuroendocrine tumors. In DIP-NECH, hyperplasia of airway neuroendocrine cells occurs without invasion beyond the basement membrane, in association with chronic inflammation or fibrosis in the lung. If the cells extend into the interstitium and are associated with fibrous tissue, the lesion is a carcinoid tumorlet (less than 5 mm) or tumor (more than 5 mm). This condition is rare, so very little data exists. Researchers have speculated that focal hyperplasia might provide a basis upon which neoplastic transformation is more likely to occur.

Several diffuse, fibrosing conditions are associated with an increased incidence of lung cancer, and may be considered preneoplastic conditions. Most recently, Hubbard and colleagues found an approximately sevenfold increase in the incidence of lung cancer in patients with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis, compared to age and sex-matched control patients, even when controlled for smoking history [10]. In fibrosis associated with pneumoconioses, such as asbestosis or silicosis, it is unclear whether the tumor development is related to the fibrosis or to the carcinogenic nature of the exposure. The tumor development in diffuse pulmonary fibrosis may be associated with AAH-like areas, consisting of hyperplasia of alveolar lining cells, which may be atypical.

Data supporting the preneoplastic nature of lesions

The data supporting the preneoplastic nature of these lesions is twofold, consisting of circumstantial evidence (lesions found in association with malignancies or in patients with high risk of developing lung cancer) and genetic evidence (genetic similarities found between tumors and their associated preneoplastic lesions).

Circumstantial evidence

Patients with primary cancer in the lung or upper aerodigestive tract have an increased risk of developing synchronous or metachronous second primaries [11]. This risk is likely to be related to chronic exposure of the bronchial tree to carcinogens. Cigarette smoke causes a field change in the mucosa with mutations demonstrable even in histologically normal areas ('field cancerization'). After smoking cessation, many of these mutations seem to persist indefinitely, so risk of lung cancer never reverts to that of a lifelong nonsmoker. Thus, broad areas of the tracheobronchial tree in high-risk patients are prone to premalignant or multifocal malignant change. The finding of these presumed premalignant lesions in cancer-bearing lungs or in patients at high risk of developing lung cancer is circumstantial evidence of the lesions' preneoplastic nature, and supports the field cancerization theory.

Several studies have shown an increased incidence of squamous metaplasia and dysplasia in the lungs of smokers. In 1979, Auerbach and colleagues described a range of histologic abnormalities in the lungs of smokers, from basal cell hyperplasia to CIS. They found dysplasia in up to 40% of heavy smokers [7,8]. In 1996, Agapitos and colleagues showed that in an autopsy study of 531 people who died of non-respiratory or non-cancer causes, the incidence of squamous metaplasia and dysplasia increased sequentially according to their degree of exposure to cigarette smoke (nonsmokers, those exposed to secondary smoke, ex-smokers and smokers) [12]. Angiogenic squamous dysplasia has also been found in the airways of smokers before the occurrence of invasive carcinoma [13].

In contrast, we still have little information about the incidence of AAH or DIP/NECH in either smoking or nonsmoking populations. Autopsy studies of AAH are hampered by the presence of coincident pathology such as pneumonia, pneumonitis, or fibrosis, which make AAH almost impossible to find. Most studies seem to show a relatively low incidence of AAH in non-cancer-bearing lungs [14,15], and DIP/NECH is an extremely rare lesion.

The increased incidence of squamous metaplasia and dysplasia, AAH, and DIP/NECH in lungs with the corresponding tumors, is strong circumstantial evidence that these lesions are preneoplastic. Squamous metaplasia, dysplasia, and CIS are frequently found in association with invasive cancer of all types [16]. It is more common to find AAH in lungs with adenocarcinoma or large cell carcinoma. The first descriptions of AAH in association with lung cancer were made in the 1980s [9,17]. Overall figures for AAH incidence range from 4.4 to 9.6% in lungs removed for benign or metastatic disease, 3.3 to 11.1% in lungs resected for squamous cell carcinoma, and 23.2 to 34.5% in lungs resected for adenocarcinoma [15,18,19]. Zones of AAH are sometimes seen around the tumor. Niho and colleagues determined that, in seven patients with AAH and BAC, the AAH lesions were all monoclonal, and in two cases the BAC and contiguous AAH had identical monoclonality [20]. These findings support the idea that the AAH-like edge that is sometimes observed around a peripheral adenocarcinoma is evidence of the pre-existing adenoma. Many patients in these and other studies had multiple AAH lesions and/or multiple synchronous primaries [18,21]. One patient was found to have 161 foci of AAH [22]. The multifocal nature of AAH may explain the multicentricity that is observed with some adenocarcinomas.

Essentially our only evidence that DIP/NECH is a preneoplastic lesion is circumstantial, based on lungs found to have concurrent carcinoid tumors and DIP/NECH, and most of the data comes from case studies [23,24]. The finding of DIP/NECH may correlate with higher grade neuroendocrine malignancy. The relation between the hyperplasia and the tumor, if any, is not currently understood.

Genetic evidence

Alterations in gene expression and chromosome structure known to be associated with malignant transformation can be demonstrated in squamous metaplasia, dysplasia and CIS, as well as in AAH. In this respect, DIP/NECH has not been studied. The changes might be sequential, and their frequency and number seem to increase with atypia in both the metaplasia-dysplasia-CIS sequence and the AAH-adenocarcinoma sequence. These changes can be seen both as proof of the preneoplastic nature of the lesions, and as possible markers of transformation (or imminent transformation). They may also become tools for early detection.

Cell proliferation markers and cell cycle regulators

Hyperproliferation and loss of cell cycle control seem to be early events in malignant transformation. Several studies have looked at different proliferation markers and cell cycle regulators in preneoplastic lesions. Staining for proliferation markers (PCNA and Ki-67) increased with increasing atypia in both squamous cell dysplasias and AAH [15,25]. Several studies have found the growth fraction in AAH is intermediate between normal lung tissue and adenocarcinoma [26,27].

Of the cell cycle regulators, P16 expression is lost in moderate dysplasia, CIS, and squamous cell carcinoma, but its loss is rare in AAH and adenocarcinoma. Cyclin D1 and E are overexpressed in hyperplasia, metaplasia, dysplasia, and CIS, as well as AAH, and increasing levels are seen with increasing grade. Levels were, however, lower in BAC. Loss of Rb (Retinoblastoma gene), which plays and important role in cell cycle regulation during G0/G1, was not seen in preinvasive lesions of either type [26,28,29].

DNA ploidy

Studies of the DNA content of cell nuclei, as a measure of chromosomal gain or loss, are used to assess the degree of nuclear aberration in a malignant cell population. Studies in both squamous cell metaplasia/dysplasia and AAH have shown progressive, increased aneuploidy with increasing atypia [17,30,31]. Hirano and colleagues showed that, in squamous metaplasia, 8% of low grade lesions and 33% of high grade lesions were aneuploid [25]. In a study of AAH, Nakanishi and colleagues demonstrated DNA aneuploidy in none of the low grade AAH, 25% of high grade, and 34.6% of BAC [32]. A few studies have shown aneuploidy of chromosome 7 in both the bronchial epithelium of patients with high risk for lung cancer (smokers, uranium miners) and in preneoplastic lesions, with an increase in the percentage of aneuploid cells from preinvasive to invasive lesions [33,34].

p53 and the p53 transcription pathway

Abnormalities of p53 expression are frequent in lung carcinoma, and many studies have found increased or abnormal p53 in both the squamous metaplasia to dysplasia sequence, and AAH. Several studies in the squamous cell carcinoma sequence have found an increase in stainable p53, with increasingly severe dysplasia, ranging in various studies from an average of 5% in low grade dysplasia to 60.4% in high grade dysplasia [25,28,29,35-38]. Studies of p53 expression in AAH have yielded similar results, showing increasing p53 expression with increasing atypia. The overall levels, however, are somewhat lower in these preneoplastic lesions indicating, perhaps, that p53 mutation is a later event in peripheral adenocarcinogenesis than in squamous carcinogenesis [15,39,40]. In contrast, the studies have found no staining in normal epithelium, and minimal staining in either metaplasia or adenomatous hyperplasia without atypia.

Other studies have looked at gene mutation instead of expression. These studies have shown that p53 gene mutation in both AAH and bronchiolar epithelial dysplasia is sometimes identical to, and sometimes different from, a concurrent tumor [41-44]. In some studies the mutations were seen with increasing frequency depending on the degree of atypia [38,41]. Brambilla and colleagues found p53 expression in all cases of SD/CIS from cancer-bearing lungs, but similar lesions from lungs with no cancer showed no staining, suggesting that stabilization of p53 in the preinvasive lesion had a high predictive value for invasion [45].

Some authors have attempted to look at the interaction between the expression of p53 and that of other members of the p53 signaling pathway. Hayashi and colleagues found that in reactive lesions there is a correlation between p53 and p21 (p53-inducible cyclin dependent kinase inhibitor) expression, and that this correlation is lost in both AAH and carcinomas [46]. Their data suggest that p21 expression may become p53 independent during transformation, even at an early AAH stage. The protein MDM-2 binds to p53 and eliminates its ability to function as a transcription factor. Alterations in MDM-2 expression have been found in preneoplastic lesions [47]. Other authors have found an apparent deregulation of the p53 apoptosis transcription pathway in precursor bronchial lesions of lung cancer. The protein, Bcl-2, inhibits programmed cell death, and overexpression provides a survival advantage. This protein is overexpressed in lung cancer (25% of squamous cell carcinoma, 10% of adenocarcinoma, 64% of small cell carcinoma) [48,49]. Overexpression has also been seen in preinvasive bronchial lesions, with some association with increasing degree of dysplasia [28,37,50]. In one of these studies, Bcl-2 overexpression was associated with Bax (an inducer of apoptosis) downregulation in preinvasive lesions and these changes were maintained during invasion [45]. Expressions of Bax, Bcl-2 and p21 did not correlate with p53 status. The authors of this study concluded that Bax/Bcl-2 imbalance contributes to clonal expansion during premalignant states.

Telomerase

Telomerase is thought to play a role in conferring immortality on tumor cell populations. It may prevent progressive telomere shortening and therefore cellular senescence. In adult somatic cells telomerase is inactive, whereas the enzyme is activated and expressed in most human cancers. Yashima and colleagues looked at telomerase expression and activity in more than 200 preneoplastic and neoplastic lesions from 40 patients: 34 with lung cancer; 5 with CIS; and 1 without lung cancer [51]. They found telomerase activity in 95–100% of CIS and invasive disease, in 70 to 80% of both hyperplastic and dysplastic bronchial epithelium, and in only 20% of normal epithelium. When they assayed activity, they found preinvasive lesions had enzyme activity only 3–4 times normal, whereas in invasive disease, activity was more than 40 times normal. Telomerase deregulation increased with increasing epithelial changes. In contrast, alveolar cells and AAH were negative for telomerase.

k-ras

The ras genes play an important role in signal transduction and cellular proliferation (through the mitogen-activated protein kinase pathways) and were among the first oncogenes identified. Mutation of k-ras is found in about 30% of non-small cell carcinoma, and is more common in adenocarcinoma than in squamous cell carcinoma. Accordingly, studies have found k-ras mutation more commonly in AAH than in SD. The AAH lesions often have different base changes at codon 12 compared to the concurrent adenocarcinoma. This finding is consistent with the notion that AAH represents field cancerization in the lung periphery [52-54]. Several studies have found that parenchymal tumors and AAH have k-ras mutation more frequently than adenocarcinoma in the airways. This finding supports the classification of adenocarcinomas into bronchial and parenchymal subtypes, and suggests the importance of AAH in development of parenchymal cancers. The bronchial subtype might arise from bronchial epithelial dysplasia [55].

FHIT

The FHIT gene (fragile histidine triad tumor suppressor gene) is frequently deleted in many carcinomas, including lung. The gene covers a genomic region at 3p14.2, which spans the most active of the common human chromosomal fragile regions FRA3B. These fragile sites might be especially susceptible to carcinogen damage. The FHIT gene encodes a protein that hydrolyzes diadenosine triphosphate to ADP and AMP in vitro. Although the in vivo function of this protein is not known, it may play a role in cell death through apoptosis and/or may affect cell proliferation. Loss of FHIT protein is the most frequent alteration in non-small cell lung carcinoma and precancerous lesions (both squamous cell and adenocarcinoma). The frequency of loss increases as the grade of dysplasia increases [56]. In some studies, loss of FHIT protein expression was almost universal by the severe SD/CIS stage. This loss is significantly more frequent in tumors and preneoplastic lesions of smokers (75%) than of nonsmokers (39%), and is an independent and more frequent event than p53 overexpression. It is more common in squamous cell carcinoma (87%) than in adenocarcinoma (57%) [57-60]. Loss of FHIT protein expression is also common in small cell carcinomas and neuroendocrine lung tumors. In one study, loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at this locus was found in atypical carcinoids as well [61].

Genomic alterations and LOH studies

Several chromosomal sites are most frequently involved in lung cancer. The most common and earliest changes in both squamous cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma seem to involve allele-specific loss of genome at 3p and 9p and perhaps 17q, among others [22,43]. These changes involve all regions of the respiratory tract, and occur with increasing frequency with increasing atypia [41,43,44,62-66]. Some of these changes have also been seen in the normal appearing bronchial epithelium of chronic smokers [67-69]. Studies suggest that these deletions occur more frequently in squamous metaplasia/dysplasia than in AAH, suggesting they may be a later event in adenocarcinoma pathogenesis [41].

In some of the most extensive studies to date, Wistuba and colleagues looked at LOH at 10 chromosomal regions frequently deleted in lung cancer [68,70]. In one study they examined normal tissue, SD, CIS, and invasive tumors from 12 patients with lung cancer. In a subsequent study they looked at 97 lung cancers and 54 preneoplastic lesions from patients without lung cancer. At one or more regions LOH was common in normal-appearing mucosa, but they found a progressive increase in overall LOH frequency and size, along with increasingly severe histopathological changes, in both lungs with lung cancer and those without. In CIS and invasive squamous cell carcinoma, 3p allele loss was almost universal. The earliest and most frequent regions of loss were at 3p21, 22–24, 25 and 9p21. Losses at 3p14.2, 14–21 began to appear in the hyperplastic/metaplastic lesions. Loss of p53 and Rb loci was present in more advanced lesions. The same allele was lost in 90% of corresponding preneoplastic and invasive lesions. The authors hypothesized that many sequentially occurring, allele-specific changes begin in independent foci of the bronchial epithelium, early in the pathogenesis of squamous cell carcinoma.

Overall, the data seem to show that localized, specific LOH of 3p and 9p occurs very early in the evolution of preinvasive disease of the bronchial epithelium. This is seen even in phenotypically normal or hyperplasic epithelium. As the lesions advance, more 3p deletions including 14.2 begin to appear, as does 17p LOH, and perhaps other regional deletions. By the time the stage of severe SD/CIS is reached, there is extensive loss of 3p and persistent loss of the 9p and 17p regions.

Methylation

Recently, there has been increased interest in the significance of the methylation of genes and their promoters. Aberrant methylation of gene promoters can silence gene expression. In an animal model exposed to tobacco carcinogen, methylation was frequent in preneoplastic lesions [71]. In human lung cancer, p16, p53 and k-ras promoter hypermethylation has been seen. Aberrant methylation of the promoter regions of other tumor suppressors may also play a role in carcinogenesis. A few studies have begun to look at methylation patterns in preneoplastic lesions. Until now, p16 tumor suppressor gene promoter methylation has been the most studied [72]. Belinsky and colleagues found that the frequency of methylation increased during progression from basal cell hyperplasia to squamous metaplasia to SD/CIS [71]. Zochbauer-Muller et al. looked at promoter methylation of multiple genes, and found that methylation was common in the promoter region of multiple genes in both tumors and associated, nonmalignant tissues [73].

Other possible markers of transformation

Vascular growth is an important aspect of malignant transformation. Increasing neovascularization and vascular count has been found with increasing dysplasia of lesions of the bronchial tree [74]. Accordingly, expression of vascular endothelial growth factor was found to increase from normal tissue to SD to CIS to invasive cancer [75]. Changes in the extracellular matrix may also distinguish normal, preinvasive, and malignant lesions. One study found increased matrix disarrangement of the basement membrane zone with increasing degree of neoplasia [76].

Many other proteins have been found to have either increased or decreased expression, correlating with increasing histopathologic abnormality. In the metaplasia-dysplasia-squamous cell carcinoma sequence, some of the proteins that may have increased expression include hyaluronan [76], epidermal growth factor receptor [36], calcyclin [77], fatty acid synthase [78], thrombomodulin [79], and epithelial cellular adhesion molecule (17-1A) [80]. In the AAH-adenocarcinoma sequence, some of the proteins with increased expression include carcinoembryonic antigen [81], surfactant apoprotein A [81] (although one study [82] found that surfactant apoprotein A seemed to decrease as the lesions advanced), cytochrome p450 [81], c-erbB2 (product of the neu oncogene) [39], and cyclooxygenase 2 [83,84].

Many other potential markers have not yet been investigated in preneoplastic lesions, but they are abnormally expressed in lung cancer. Expression of Hif1α is increased in most types of malignancy, including lung [85]. A tumor suppressor gene, Rb-related gene pRb2/p130, may play a role in lung cancer development [86]. Expression of the 14-3-3 family of proteins is increased in lung cancer tissues [87]. Another potential marker is HnRNPB1, a protein that is found in 100% of squamous cell carcinoma of the lung, and expression in the sputum has been correlated with risk of lung cancer development in certain populations [88,89]. The presence of DNA adducts may also potentially identify preneoplastic lesions [90].

Clinical studies of lesions and risks of progression

The cause and effect relationship between these various genetic abnormalities and morphologic changes is unknown. Given the relationship between many of these finding and the grades of atypia, abnormal gene expression might be responsible for the changes in morphology. The phenotype/histology, however, is reversible in some cases. Very few clinical studies have looked at the outcome of preneoplastic lesions. Based on studies of epithelial dysplasia in sputum samples, it might take up to 10 years for invasion to occur [91]. Some studies have shown that when atypia is seen in the sputum, it may take 6–36 months for a lesion to be visible bronchoscopically [6]. In a study of patients who underwent fluorescence bronchoscopy at regular intervals for at least six months, progression to invasive cancer occurred in 5/9 patients with CIS. Neoplastic lesions were detected at other sites in 4/9 patients [92]. Ponticello and colleagues followed a group of smokers without lung cancer for four years. Initially, 22 bronchial dysplastic lesions were detected. Ten lung cancers developed during follow up, seven of which developed in lesions that had expressed p53. The authors suggested that p53 immunohistochemistry can identify the bronchial preneoplastic lesions that will progress to lung cancer [93].

It is almost impossible to follow AAH in a longitudinal study, since the lesions are generally only identified incidentally in lung resected for other reasons. It has been found that, in patients who have had resections for adenocarcinoma, the concurrent presence of AAH does not appear to affect survival [19,94]. In one study the concurrent presence of AAH actually seemed to be a favorable prognostic indicator [95]. The fate of DIP/NECH is also unknown.

Conclusion

Although great strides have been made in the last decade in describing the sequence of lung carcinogenesis, we need much more information to effectively intervene in this process. Studies in the last few years have clearly shown that there is an accumulation of various genetic abnormalities, which correlate with increasing morphologic changes, in both the squamous cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma sequence. Very little is known so far about the details of carcinoid/neuroendocrine or small cell carcinoma development. Changes in the p53 gene and 3p LOH have been the most extensively studied mutations, however there are many other potential markers. We do not know which genetic changes are most important, or at what stage the process is irreversible. It is likely that several different combinations of abnormalities can cause transformation. Improvements in CT technology may allow us to detect AAH in vivo, and advances in bronchoscopy, including fluorescence bronchoscopy, may aid in the detection of preneoplastic central bronchial lesions (although to date, the specificity is relatively low). Even if we are able to detect the histologic preneoplastic lesions, however, we still do not know the risk of progression. The histologic lesions may be reversible if carcinogen exposure ceases, although the genomic alterations do not regress. Therefore, if we are to affect lung cancer mortality, it is important to identify the genetic lesions that predispose to malignant transformation so that these can be detected along with the more variable histologic changes. Just as importantly, there is a need to develop a means to prevent this transformation. In this review we have summarized the available information on genetic and biochemical changes in presumed preneoplastic lesions of the bronchial epithelium. This review thus provides a basis for further investigations in this area.

Abbreviations

AAH = atypical adenomatous hyperplasia; BAC = bronchoalveolar cell carcinoma; CIS = carcinoma in situ; CT = computerized tomography; DIP-NECH = diffuse idiopathic pulmonary neuroendocrine cell hyperplasia; LOH = loss of heterozygosity; SD = squamous dysplasia; WHO = World Health Organization.