M Eddleston1, L Szinicz, P Eyer, N Buckley. 1. Centre for Tropical Medicine, Nuffield Department of Clinical Medicine, University of Oxford, UK. eddlestonm@eureka.lk
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Acute organophosphorus (OP) pesticide poisoning is widespread in the developing world. Standard treatment involves the administration of intravenous atropine and an oxime to counter acetylcholinesterase inhibition at the synapse, but the usefulness of oximes is uncertain. AIM: To assess the evidence on the use of oximes in OP poisoning. DESIGN: Systematic review. METHODS: We searched Medline, Embase, and Cochrane databases (last check 01/02/02) for 'organophosphate' or 'oxime' together with 'poisoning' or 'overdose'. We cross-referenced from other articles, and contacted experts to identify unpublished studies. A Web search engine [www.google.com] was also used, with the keywords 'organophosphate', 'oxime', and 'trial' (last check 01/02/02). RESULTS: We found two randomized controlled trials (RCTs) involving 182 patients treated with pralidoxime. The RCTs found no benefit with pralidoxime, and have been used to argue that pralidoxime should not be used in OP poisoning. DISCUSSION: The RCT authors must be congratulated for attempting important studies in a difficult environment. However, their studies did not take into account recently clarified issues regarding outcome, and their methodology is unclear. A generalized statement that pralidoxime should not be used in OP poisoning is not supported by the published results. Oximes may well be irrelevant in the overwhelming self-poisoning typical of the tropics, but a large RCT comparing the current WHO-recommended pralidoxime regimen (>30 mg/kg bolus followed by >8 mg/kg/h infusion) with placebo is needed for a definitive answer. Such a study should be designed to identify any patient subgroups that might benefit from oximes.
BACKGROUND: Acute organophosphorus (OP) pesticide poisoning is widespread in the developing world. Standard treatment involves the administration of intravenous atropine and an oxime to counter acetylcholinesterase inhibition at the synapse, but the usefulness of oximes is uncertain. AIM: To assess the evidence on the use of oximes in OP poisoning. DESIGN: Systematic review. METHODS: We searched Medline, Embase, and Cochrane databases (last check 01/02/02) for 'organophosphate' or 'oxime' together with 'poisoning' or 'overdose'. We cross-referenced from other articles, and contacted experts to identify unpublished studies. A Web search engine [www.google.com] was also used, with the keywords 'organophosphate', 'oxime', and 'trial' (last check 01/02/02). RESULTS: We found two randomized controlled trials (RCTs) involving 182 patients treated with pralidoxime. The RCTs found no benefit with pralidoxime, and have been used to argue that pralidoxime should not be used in OP poisoning. DISCUSSION: The RCT authors must be congratulated for attempting important studies in a difficult environment. However, their studies did not take into account recently clarified issues regarding outcome, and their methodology is unclear. A generalized statement that pralidoxime should not be used in OP poisoning is not supported by the published results. Oximes may well be irrelevant in the overwhelming self-poisoning typical of the tropics, but a large RCT comparing the current WHO-recommended pralidoxime regimen (>30 mg/kg bolus followed by >8 mg/kg/h infusion) with placebo is needed for a definitive answer. Such a study should be designed to identify any patient subgroups that might benefit from oximes.
Authors: M Eddleston; S Rajapakse; S Jayalath; L Sjöström; W Santharaj; P N Thenabadu; M H Sheriff; D A Warrell Journal: Lancet Date: 2000-03-18 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Francine S Katz; Stevan Pecic; Timothy H Tran; Ilya Trakht; Laura Schneider; Zhengxiang Zhu; Long Ton-That; Michal Luzac; Viktor Zlatanic; Shivani Damera; Joanne Macdonald; Donald W Landry; Liang Tong; Milan N Stojanovic Journal: Chembiochem Date: 2015-09-09 Impact factor: 3.164
Authors: Caio R D Assis; Amanda G Linhares; Mariana P Cabrera; Vagne M Oliveira; Kaline C C Silva; Marina Marcuschi; Elba V M Maciel Carvalho; Ranilson S Bezerra; Luiz B Carvalho Journal: Environ Sci Pollut Res Int Date: 2018-05-24 Impact factor: 4.223
Authors: Michael Eddleston; Peter Eyer; Franz Worek; Edmund Juszczak; Nicola Alder; Fahim Mohamed; Lalith Senarathna; Ariyasena Hittarage; Shifa Azher; K Jeganathan; Shaluka Jayamanne; Ludwig von Meyer; Andrew H Dawson; Mohamed Hussain Rezvi Sheriff; Nick A Buckley Journal: PLoS Med Date: 2009-06-30 Impact factor: 11.069
Authors: Polwattage M S Perera; Shaluka F Jayamanna; Raja Hettiarachchi; Chandana Abeysinghe; Harindra Karunatilake; Andrew H Dawson; Nick A Buckley Journal: Trials Date: 2009-08-20 Impact factor: 2.279