Cyclopropylcarbinyl-type ring openings. Reconciling the chemistry of neutral radicals and radical anions.

Cyclopropylcarbinyl --> homoallyl and related rearrangements of radical ions (a) are frequently used as mechanistic "probes" to detect the occurrence of single electron transfer in chemical and biochemical processes, (b) provide the basis for mechanism-based drug design, and (c) are important tools in organic synthesis. Unfortunately, these rearrangements are poorly understood, especially with respect to the effect of substrate structure on reactivity. Frequently, researchers assume that the same factors which govern the reactivity of neutral free radicals also pertain to radical ions. The results reported herein demonstrate that in some cases structure-reactivity trends in radical ion rearrangements are very different from neutral radicals. For radical ions, delocalizations of both charge and spin are important factors governing their reactivity.