A McGonigal1, M Oto, A J C Russell, J Greene, R Duncan. 1. Department of Neurology, Institute of Neurological Sciences, Southern General Hospital, Glasgow, UK. aileenmcg@hotmail.com
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To assess the yield of recorded habitual non-epileptic seizures during outpatient video EEG, using simple suggestion techniques based on hyperventilation and photic stimulation. DESIGN: Randomised controlled trial of "suggestion" v "no suggestion" during outpatient video EEG recording. SETTING: Regional epilepsy service (tertiary care; single centre). PARTICIPANTS: 30 patients (22 female, 8 male), aged over 16 years, with a probable clinical diagnosis of non-epileptic seizures; 15 were randomised to each group. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Yield of habitual non-epileptic seizures recorded, and requirement for additional inpatient video EEG. RESULTS: 10/15 patients had habitual non-epileptic seizures with suggestion; 5/15 had non-epileptic seizures with no suggestion (p = 0.058; NS); 8/9 patients with a history of previous events in medical settings had non-epileptic seizures recorded during study. Logistic regression analysis with an interaction clause showed a significant effect of suggestion in patients with a history of previous events in medical settings (p = 0.003). An additional inpatient video-EEG was avoided in 14 of the 30 patients (47%). CONCLUSIONS:Habitual non-epileptic seizures can be recorded reliably during short outpatient video EEG in selected patients. Simple (non-invasive) suggestion techniques increase the yield at least in the subgroup with a history of previous events in medical settings. Inpatient video EEG can be avoided in some patients.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To assess the yield of recorded habitual non-epilepticseizures during outpatient video EEG, using simple suggestion techniques based on hyperventilation and photic stimulation. DESIGN: Randomised controlled trial of "suggestion" v "no suggestion" during outpatient video EEG recording. SETTING: Regional epilepsy service (tertiary care; single centre). PARTICIPANTS: 30 patients (22 female, 8 male), aged over 16 years, with a probable clinical diagnosis of non-epilepticseizures; 15 were randomised to each group. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Yield of habitual non-epilepticseizures recorded, and requirement for additional inpatient video EEG. RESULTS: 10/15 patients had habitual non-epilepticseizures with suggestion; 5/15 had non-epilepticseizures with no suggestion (p = 0.058; NS); 8/9 patients with a history of previous events in medical settings had non-epilepticseizures recorded during study. Logistic regression analysis with an interaction clause showed a significant effect of suggestion in patients with a history of previous events in medical settings (p = 0.003). An additional inpatient video-EEG was avoided in 14 of the 30 patients (47%). CONCLUSIONS: Habitual non-epilepticseizures can be recorded reliably during short outpatient video EEG in selected patients. Simple (non-invasive) suggestion techniques increase the yield at least in the subgroup with a history of previous events in medical settings. Inpatient video EEG can be avoided in some patients.
Authors: Philipp S Reif; Laurent M Willems; Adam Strzelczyk; Karl Martin Klein; Felix Rosenow Journal: Herzschrittmacherther Elektrophysiol Date: 2018-05-14
Authors: Adrien Gras; Alistair Wardrope; Edouard Hirsch; Ali A Asadi Pooya; Rod Duncan; David Gigineishvili; Coraline Hingray; Kousuke Kanemoto; Lady Ladino; William Curt LaFrance; Aileen McGonigal; Chrisma Pretorius; Paola Valenti Hirsch; Pierre Vidailhet; Dong Zhou; Markus Reuber Journal: Epilepsia Open Date: 2021-07-31