Detection of Y-specific sequences in 122 patients with Turner syndrome: nested PCR is not a reliable method.

The incidence of Y chromosome sequences in patients with Turner syndrome has been evaluated in several studies, and its frequency varied from 0% to 61%, depending on the molecular methodology used. The aim of our study was to screen for Y chromosome sequences in 122 patients with Turner syndrome without cytogenetic evidence of this chromosome. DNA of 100 normal women was also screened and it was used as a negative control. To identify cryptic Y mosaicism, eight regions of Y chromosome were amplified by PCR. In order to increase the sensitivity of Y sequence detection, a nested PCR of the SRY and TSPY genes was also performed. All patients had several stigmata of Turner syndrome and none of them presented with signs of virilization. The most frequent karyotype was 45,X (54.1%), followed by mosaicism involving structural aberration of the X chromosome. There were 12 patients who carried a marker or ring chromosome. First-round PCR identified Y chromosome sequences in only four patients (3%), and all of them had a chromosome mosaicism with at least one cell lineage with a marker chromosome. After nested PCR, 25% of the patients and 14% of the normal women were positive for the presence of Y sequences. Contamination with extraneous genomic DNA was ruled out by microsatellite studies, but we cannot eliminate the possibility of contamination with PCR products, despite careful handling. We conclude that nested PCR overestimated the frequency of Y sequences in patients with Turner syndrome and should be avoided to prevent false positive results, which lead to unnecessary surgical treatment of these patients. Copyright 2001 Wiley-Liss, Inc.