The diagnostic value of liver biopsy.

BACKGROUND: Since the introduction of molecular diagnostic tools such as markers for hepatitis C and different autoimmune diseases, liver biopsy is thought to be useful mainly for staging but not for diagnostic purposes. The aim was to review the liver biopsies for 5 years after introduction of testing for hepatitis C, in order to evaluate what diagnostic insights - if any - remain after serologic testing.
METHODS: Retrospective review of all liver biopsies performed between 1.1.1995 and 31.12.1999 at an academic outpatient hepatology department. The diagnoses suspected in the biopsy note were compared with the final diagnosis arrived at during a joint meeting with the responsible clinicians and a hepatopathologist.
RESULTS: In 365 patients, 411 diagnoses were carried out before biopsy. 84.4 % were confirmed by biopsy but in 8.8 %, 6.8 % and 10.5 % the diagnosis was specified, changed or a diagnosis added, respectively. Additional diagnoses of clinical relevance were unrecognized biliary obstruction and additional alcoholic liver disease in patients with chronic hepatitis C. Liver biopsy led to change in management for 12.1 % of patients.
CONCLUSION: Even in the era of advanced virological, immunological and molecular genetic testing, liver biopsy remains a useful diagnostic tool. The yield is particularly high in marker negative patients but also in patients with a clear-cut prebiopsy diagnosis, liver biopsy can lead to changes in patient management.

Background

Liver biopsy has been the gold standard for diagnosing liver disease; however, the detection of the hepatitis C virus and the development diagnostic testing [1], the development of criteria for autoimmune hepatitis [2] as well as the detection of novel autoantibodies [3] makes diagnosis of many liver diseases based on virological and serological testing much easier and precise.

We had shown in an earlier study before anti-HCV testing became available that liver biopsy changed diagnosis and management in a sizable percentage of cases [4]. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the diagnostic value of liver biopsy in the era of testing for hepatitis C. To this effect, we retrospectively analyzed the 380 liver biopsies performed between 1.1.1995 to 31.12.1999 in our department.

Methods

The charts of all patients who underwent percutaneous liver biopsy in the Department between 1.1.1995 to 31.12.1999 were reviewed and pre- and postbiopsy diagnosis extracted. Liver biopsies were performed on an outpatient basis either by the Menghini technique after ultrasound examination of the liver or by direct ultra-sound guided biopsy. The choice of the method was left to the attending physician. To qualify for outpatient liver biopsy prothrombin time as assessed by the Quick value had to be above 60 %, platelets > 60'000 and there had to be no history of excessive bleeding. Moreover, patients with focal lesions, dilated bile ducts or signs of hepatic decompensation were excluded.

Prebiopsy diagnosis was done based on history, physical examination and extensive laboratory investigations. The prebiopsy diagnosis was recorded in the biopsy note by the physician performing the liver biopsy. More than one diagnosis was possible per patient. Hepatitis B was suspected when HBs and/or anti-HBc were present. Hepatitis C was diagnosed based on a positive anti-HCV test; in such patients HCV-RNA was also determined. Autoimmune hepatitis was suspected when IgG were elevated and/or when autoantibodies (ANA, ASM, SLA, LKM) were present. Primary biliary cirrhosis was suspected in the presence of a cholestatic enzyme pattern and positive antimitochondrial antibodies. Hemochromatosis was suspected when iron saturation was above 45 and 50 % in women and men, respectively and with ferritin in the pathological range. Alcoholic liver disease was suspected when a corresponding history was present and/or with an AST/ALT ratio above 1 and a markedly elevated – glutamyl transpeptidase. Non-alcoholic steatohepatitis / steatosis was suspected when there was a negative history for alcohol abuse, usually confirmed by a third person. Wilson's disease was suspected in patients with low serum coeruloplasmin and elevated urinary copper excretion. α1-antitrypsin deficiency was invoked when serum α1-antitrypsin was low.

Post-biopsy diagnosis was arrived at in a common conference where the biopsy and all serological tests were reviewed together with the hepatopathologist (AZ). Grading and staging was done according to Batts and Ludwig [5].

Liver and other biochemical tests were performed by standard autoanalyzer methods in the central clinical laboratory of the university hospital. Serum bile acids were determined by a commercially available radioimmunoassay. Galactose elimination capacity was determined as previously described [6,7] and the aminopyrine breath test using 13C-dimethyl-aminopyrine instead of the previously reported 14C-labeled compound [8].

Results are reported as median and range or mean ± standard deviation as indicated in the text. Predictive value of the different tests with respect to activity and stage was performed using Statistica (Statsoft Inc., Tulsa OK). Multiple analysis of variance was performed with the respective module; significant differences were localized by Tukey's honest significant difference test.

Results

In the period reviewed – 1.1.1995 – 31.12.1999 – liver biopsy was performed on an outpatient basis in 380 patients. In three patients no material could be obtained; another 12 liver biopsies were performed in transplanted patients. Since most of our liver biopsies in transplanted patients are performed on an inpatient basis these 12 biopsies were not further analyzed leaving 365 biopsies as the basis for this report.

There were 126 female and 239 male patients with a median age of 42 (range 16–75) years. The main laboratory findings are given in table 1. Besides the diagnostic categories listed in table 1 there were four cases of Kupffer cell siderosis, 4 cases were normal or could not be classified, 3 patients underwent staging biopsy for Hodgkin's lymphoma, 3 cases of α1-antitrypsin deficiency, 2 granulomatous hepatitis and one each of nodular regenerative hyperplasia and vasculitis in the context of Wegener's granulomatosis.

Table 1

Main laboratory parameters in the different diagnostic groups. Median and range are given.

Final Dx	N	BR	ALT	Alk. P.	γ-GT	Albumin	Ferritin	GEC	ABT
CHC	215	11	105	69	48	39	152	5.6	0.6
		3–51	12–852	26–240	6–1105	27–53	7–4404	3.3–8.8	.04–1.76
(N)ASH	68	14	72	90	119	38	311	5.7	.43
		7–126	20–852	42–333	12–2930	25–48	7–4404	3.4–8.3	.03–1.23
CHB	37	14	120	71	30	37	129	5.4	.58
		5–32	18–510	39–1074	7–754	27–45	86–532	3.7–6.9	.09–.84
HC	24	12	65	84	35	37	857	5.7	.55
		5–55	16–224	62–142	7–260	22–50	237–3729	4.0–8.0	.15–1.76
PBC	23	11	82	171	175	36	101	5.9	.66
		5–134	13–423	68–566	26–1505	32–40	10–812	3.0–8.3	.22–1.34
AIH	11	22	242	117	91	32	196	5.5	.40
		5–522	22–1360	78–283	40–600	24–41	8–4013	3.0–7.1	.04–.70
CHOL	9	17	65	98	218	40	95	6.9	.51
		4–25	23–293	69–274	106–1199	24–43	40–333	4.6–6.9	.42–.54

There were 411 diagnoses before biopsy; 347 (84.4 %) of which were confirmed by biopsy. In 64 cases diagnosis was specified (36; 8.8 %), changed (28; 6.8 %) or added (43; 10.5 %). The details of these changes in diagnoses are compiled in table 2. There were 43 diagnoses not considered before performing the liver biopsy added after liver biopsy (table 3). In the post-biopsy evaluation, 311 patients carried one, 50 patients two and 4 three diagnoses.

Table 2

Modification of diagnosis by liver biopsy

Pre-biopsy (n)	Diagnosis changed	Diagnosis specified
Steatosis / NASH (18)	Cholestasis (2)	Alcoholic hepatitis (3)
	Chronic hepatitis (1)	NASH (5)
	Gran. Hepatitis (1)	Alcoholic cirrhosis (1)
		Steatosis (5)
Alcoholic liver disease (12)	No evidence of ALD (7)	Steatosis (2)
		Alcoholic hepatitis (3)
Ai liver disease (11)	Ruled out (1)	Ai cholangiopathy (3)
	Portal fibrosis (1)	PBC (1)
	Steatosis (1)	Overlap syndrome (4)
Hemochromatosis (8)	Ruled out (5)	Kupffer cell siderosis (3)
Cholestasis (7)	Toxic hepatitis (1)	Obstruction (2)
	Alcoholic hepatitis (1)	Ai cholangiopathy (1)
	Autoimmune hepatitis (1)	PSC (1)
Cryptogenic cirrhosis (4)	Portal fibrosis (1)	Ai hepatitis (1)
	Steatosis (1)	PSC (1)
Wilson's disease (3)	Ruled out (3)
Toxic hepatitis (1)	Alcoholic hepatitis (1)

Ai stands for autoimmune, PSC and PBC for primary sclerosing cholangitis and primary biliary cirrhosis, respectively. Toxic hepatitis infers drug or industrial toxin-induced liver damage.

Table 3

Diagnoses added to a bioptically confirmed diagnosis

Confirmed diagnosis (n)	Added diagnosis (n)
Hepatitis C (30)	Alcoholic liver disease (17)
	Steatosis (3)
	NASH (2)
	Iron overload (6)
	Autoimmune hepatitis (1)
	Granulomatous hepatitis (1)
Iron overload (5)	Hepatitis C (2)
	Alcoholic liver disease (2)
	Steatosis (1)
PBC (3) or PSC (1)	Steatosis (2)
	Alcoholic liver disease (1)
Steatosis (3)	Cholestasis (2)
	Biliary obstruction (1)
Alcoholic liver disease (1)	Chronic hepatitis C (1)
Chronic hepatitis B (1)	Steatosis (1)

There were 32 (8.8 %) patients with marker negative liver disease (No autoantibodies, HBs and anti-HBc negative, anti-HCV negative, iron parameters not suggesting hemochromatosis, ALT/AST ratio + γ-GT + MCV not suggestive of alcohol abuse). The findings in this group are reported in table 4. The most frequent prebiopsy diagnoses were steatosis and unknown hepatopathy in 14 and 9 patients, respectively. The most frequent postbiopsy diagnosis was steatosis or alcoholic liver disease in 14 patients. Only one biopsy was reported as normal. Clinically relevant diagnoses – leading to changes in management or further diagnostic testing were found in 5 patients, namely 3 cases of obstruction and two of marker negative autoimmune hepatitis.

Table 4

Pre- and postbiopsy diagnoses in marker negative liver disease

Pre-biopsy diagnosis	Postbiopsy diagnosis
Steatosis (14)	Steatosis (9)
	Cholestasis (2)
	Obstruction (1)
	Granulomatous hepatitis (1)
	Chronic active hepatitis (1)
Unknown (9)	Steatosis (2)
	Autoimmune hepatitis (1)
	Obstruction (1)
	Granulomatous hepatitis (1)
	Sepsis (1)
	Nodular regenerative hyperplasia (1)
	Vasculitis (1)
	Normal (1)
Cholestasis (4)	Alcoholic liver disease (1)
	Obstruction (1)
	PSC (2)
Alcoholic liver disease (3)	Alcoholic liver disease (2)
	PSC (1)
Autoimmune hepatitis (1)	Autoimmune hepatitis (1)
Toxic hepatitis (1)	Toxic hepatitis (1)

The different liver tests (ALT, alkaline phosphatase, γ-GT, bilirubin, albumin, prothrombin time, serum bile acids, galactose elimination capacity and aminopyrine breath test were analyzed for their potential to recognize stage in the major diagnostic groups reported in table 1. Overall, there was a marked effect of fibrosis on the liver tests by multiple analysis of variance for all patients (Rao's R 3.77 p < 10-6); localization of differences (Tukey's honest significance test) revealed that prothrombin time and platelet count differentiated between stage 4 and the other stages. Only galactose elimination capacity was able to differentiate between all stages (figure 1) but the overlap was too large to make this clinically relevant. Similar results were obtained when only patients with viral hepatitis (Rao's R 3.66, p < 10-6) were tested but not for patients with alcoholic liver disease or NASH; the n in the other groups was too small to perform analysis of variance. None of the liver tests including ALT predicted activity in the whole patient group or in the patients with hepatitis C and/or B.

Figure 1

Box and whisker plot of galactose elimination capacity (GEC) in different stages of liver disease. Staging was performed according to Batts and Ludwig [5]. Means, standard deviations and standard errors of the mean are indicated. Galactose elimination capacity was the only test differing significantly (p < 0.05) between all stages.

There were was one major complication in this series: one patient had to be hospitalized because of a bile leak and associated severe pain. Sonography performed two weeks earlier had been normal while postbiopsy sonography demonstrated dilated bile ducts and further work-up showed a small ampullary carcinoma. Two other patients had to be hospitalized over night because of severe pain after liver biopsy; in none of them was there any signficant pathology revealed by sonography and careful follow-up; both were discharged free of pain the next morning.

Discussion

Our data demonstrate that liver biopsy even in this age of advanced serological testing modified or added to diagnosis in a sizable percentage of cases. While this was not clinically relevant or represented a more precise diagnostic label (e.g. overlap syndrome when the prebiopsy diagnosis was primary biliary cirrhosis), it led to additional diagnoses which affected the patients clinical management in at least 12 cases (3.3 %) to a major and in another 41 (8.8%) in a minor fashion. The number of changed diagnoses is similar to that reported in asymptomatic patients from the Mayo clinic [9] and – surprisingly – remains comparable to that others and ourselves had reported in the pre-hepatitis C testing era [10,4].

Hepatitis C was the most common indication for liver biopsy in our patient population, an experience similar to that reported recently from France [11]. It is not surprising that diagnosis was modified most often in this disease, the finding of additional toxic damage due to ethanol being the most frequent finding (table 3). In spite of a thorough history and assessment of the usual markers of alcohol abuse significant alcohol toxicity was discovered only in the biopsy in 17 patients (7.9 %). This is quite a relevant finding as alcohol intake is a well known modifier of disease progression in chronic hepatitis C [12]. In one case each autoimmune and granulomatous hepatitis were found. The prevalence of granulomata was thus much rarer in our series (0.5 %) than the 10 % reported recently in hepatitis C [13].

This report deals with only day-care procedures which has been the standard in our institution for the past 20 years; this has been shown to markedly enhance patient acceptance [11]. It could bias the findings somewhat, however, since patients with advanced liver disease, most patients after orthotopic liver transplantation and patients with focal lesions were hospitalized for liver biopsy and not analyzed in the present report. We had only one major complication in this series which could have been avoided had sonography been performed the day of the biopsy. Thus, Lindor et al. reported that sonography markedly reduced morbidity and hospitalization [14].

Of particular interest when investigating the diagnostic value of liver biopsy is the marker negative patient. This constellation was found in 8.8 % of our patients, a percentage similar to that recently reported by other investigators [15,16]. In the series of Daniel et al. mostly steatosis was detected [15]; therefore, they found liver biopsy only useful for staging. Our results are more resembling those of Berasain and colleagues [16] where relevant pathology other than steatosis or NASH was detected in almost half of the patients. In our series there were several unexpected diagnoses made which affected patient management (table 4). Berasain et al. also found HBV-DNA or HCV-RNA in 26.7 % of patients with marker negative liver disease [16]; in our series we did not test routinely for these viruses when the usual markers were negative.

The value of liver biopsy in staging remains uncontested [17]; in line with other investigations [18,19] we found none of the usual liver tests to predict fibrosis or cirrhosis. Platelets and prothrombin time were significantly lower in patients with stage 4 disease but the overlap was too large to make this a clinically useful parameter; this is in line with a recent investigation in hepatitis C where the Bonacini score (consisting of AST/ALT ratio, platelet count and INR) was unable to reliably predict stage [19]. The only test differing significantly between the five stages was the galactose elimination capacity. This is in line with a smaller series of patients with hepatitis C reported by Mion and colleagues [20]; again the overlap was too large to give this difference clinical significance, however. Besides the staging, the liver biopsy gives several clues with respect to anticipated response to interferon treatment [21].

To which extent markers of fibrosis such as PIIIP, collagen IV and serum hyaluronate could replace the liver biopsy in staging cannot be answered from our study since none of these markers had been measured in our patients. However, good specificity and sensitivity has been reported by several investigators, in particular for hyaluronate [22-24]. Recently, a combination of different serum proteins, serum bilirubin and g-glutamyltranspeptidase has been reported to be useful in predicting fibrosis in patients with chronic hepatitis C [25].

Conclusion

In conclusion, even with advanced serological testing unrecognized diseases can be found in liver biopsy in a sizable number of patients. In the present study this was particularly true for hepatitis C, where additional diagnoses – in particular alcoholic liver disease – was found in the biopsy in over half of all patients. This leads to changes in management in about 5 % of patients. Liver biopsy remains a useful diagnostic tool not only for staging, but also for diagnostic purposes.

Competing interests

none

Pre-publication history

The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here: