G B Shulman1, N R Connelly. 1. Department of Anesthesiology, Marshfield Clinic, Marshfield, WI, USA
Abstract
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To compare the Bullard laryngoscope (BL) with the flexible fiberoptic bronchoscope (FFB) in a cervical spine injury model, using inline stabilization. DESIGN: Randomized clinical trial. SETTING: Main operating room of a tertiary care hospital. PATIENTS: 50 adult, ASA physical status I, II, and III patients undergoing an elective general anesthetic. INTERVENTIONS: Each patient's trachea was intubated with both techniques. Cricoid pressure was applied to half of the study patients. MEASUREMENTS: The time for laryngoscopic view and the time to intubation were recorded for each technique. The effects of cricoid pressure on laryngoscopic view and intubation time were determined. MAIN RESULTS: The times for laryngoscopy and intubation were longer in the FFB group than in the BL group (p < 0.004). There was a significantly lower success rate of laryngoscopy view in the FFB group in the presence of cricoid pressure (15 of 25 patients, or 60%) than either of the BL groups or the FFB no-cricoid pressure group. CONCLUSIONS: The BL is more reliable, quicker, and more resistant to the effects of cricoid pressure than is the FFB.
RCT Entities:
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To compare the Bullard laryngoscope (BL) with the flexible fiberoptic bronchoscope (FFB) in a cervical spine injury model, using inline stabilization. DESIGN: Randomized clinical trial. SETTING: Main operating room of a tertiary care hospital. PATIENTS: 50 adult, ASA physical status I, II, and III patients undergoing an elective general anesthetic. INTERVENTIONS: Each patient's trachea was intubated with both techniques. Cricoid pressure was applied to half of the study patients. MEASUREMENTS: The time for laryngoscopic view and the time to intubation were recorded for each technique. The effects of cricoid pressure on laryngoscopic view and intubation time were determined. MAIN RESULTS: The times for laryngoscopy and intubation were longer in the FFB group than in the BL group (p < 0.004). There was a significantly lower success rate of laryngoscopy view in the FFB group in the presence of cricoid pressure (15 of 25 patients, or 60%) than either of the BL groups or the FFB no-cricoid pressure group. CONCLUSIONS: The BL is more reliable, quicker, and more resistant to the effects of cricoid pressure than is the FFB.
Authors: Catherine M Algie; Robert K Mahar; Hannah B Tan; Greer Wilson; Patrick D Mahar; Jason Wasiak Journal: Cochrane Database Syst Rev Date: 2015-11-18