A J Moskowitz1, E A Rose, A C Gelijns. 1. International Center for Health Outcomes and Innovation Research, Department of Surgery, College of Physicians and Surgeons, The Joseph L Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, New York, New York 10032, USA. ajm4@columbia.edu
Abstract
BACKGROUND: With increasing use of left ventricular assist devices (LVAD) worldwide, the economics of LVAD implantation have become an important focus of concern. Although these devices have high unit costs, they are the only hope for survival for a large group of terminally ill patients and are likely to have an expansion in indications for use. METHODS: We calculated the costs associated with long-term LVAD implantation. We used the ratio of cost-to-charges method to calculate hospital costs per resource category, market prices for drugs and device, and payments for physician services. RESULTS: Based on our experience with "bridge-to-transplantation" patients, we estimated average first-year costs to be $222,460 including professional fees and $192,154 excluding professional fees. The latter figure is comparable to average first-year costs for cardiac transplantation, which is $176,605 without professional fees at our institution. CONCLUSIONS: The costs of LVAD therapy will change after the first year of implantation, and device reliability and longevity will be important factors in determining these costs. Should the costs of LVAD therapy continue to track those of cardiac transplantation, devices will be cost-effective only if they offer similar efficacy to cardiac transplantation.
BACKGROUND: With increasing use of left ventricular assist devices (LVAD) worldwide, the economics of LVAD implantation have become an important focus of concern. Although these devices have high unit costs, they are the only hope for survival for a large group of terminally ill patients and are likely to have an expansion in indications for use. METHODS: We calculated the costs associated with long-term LVAD implantation. We used the ratio of cost-to-charges method to calculate hospital costs per resource category, market prices for drugs and device, and payments for physician services. RESULTS: Based on our experience with "bridge-to-transplantation" patients, we estimated average first-year costs to be $222,460 including professional fees and $192,154 excluding professional fees. The latter figure is comparable to average first-year costs for cardiac transplantation, which is $176,605 without professional fees at our institution. CONCLUSIONS: The costs of LVAD therapy will change after the first year of implantation, and device reliability and longevity will be important factors in determining these costs. Should the costs of LVAD therapy continue to track those of cardiac transplantation, devices will be cost-effective only if they offer similar efficacy to cardiac transplantation.
Authors: Guilherme V Silva; Emerson C Perin; Hans F R Dohmann; Radovan Borojevic; Suzana A Silva; Andre L S Sousa; Joao A R Assad; William K Vaughn; Claudio T Mesquita; Luciano Belém; Antonio C Carvalho; Hans J F Dohmann; Ellen Barroso do Amaral; Joaquim Coutinho; Rodrigo Branco; Edie Oliveira; James T Willerson Journal: Tex Heart Inst J Date: 2004
Authors: Subha V Raman; Anurag Sahu; Ali Z Merchant; Louis B Louis; Michael S Firstenberg; Benjamin Sun Journal: J Heart Lung Transplant Date: 2009-09-26 Impact factor: 10.247