M Alam1, M Stiller. 1. Department of Dermatology, College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia University, New York, NY, USA. murad@alam.com
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To determine which treatment modalities for condylomata acuminata are associated with the lowest direct medical costs. DESIGN: Cost-effectiveness analysis. SETTING: Ambulatory private practice, primary or specialty care. PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS: Adults with no presenting complaints other than condylomata acuminata. INTERVENTIONS: Construction of a cost-effectiveness model. From a literature review, extraction of commonly accepted guidelines regarding duration and frequency as well as reports of efficacies of typical treatment regimens; from Medicare physician fee schedules, costs of physician visits and physician-administered treatments; from published data, average wholesale prices of medications. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Estimated direct medical costs per complete clearance associated with different treatment options for condylomata acuminata. RESULTS: Mean direct medical costs per complete clearance are lowest for surgical excision ($285). Other low-cost modalities are loop electrosurgical excision procedure ($316), electrodesiccation ($347), carbon dioxide laser ($416), podofilox ($424), and pulsed-dye laser ($479). Higher-cost modalities are cryotherapy ($951), trichloroacetic acid ($986), imiquimod ($1255), podophyllum resin ($1632), and interferon alfa-2b ($6665). CONCLUSION: Surgical modalities, including excision, electrodesiccation, loop electrosurgical excision procedure, and laser, as well as podofilox are low-cost options for the treatment of condylomata acuminata.
OBJECTIVE: To determine which treatment modalities for condylomata acuminata are associated with the lowest direct medical costs. DESIGN: Cost-effectiveness analysis. SETTING: Ambulatory private practice, primary or specialty care. PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS: Adults with no presenting complaints other than condylomata acuminata. INTERVENTIONS: Construction of a cost-effectiveness model. From a literature review, extraction of commonly accepted guidelines regarding duration and frequency as well as reports of efficacies of typical treatment regimens; from Medicare physician fee schedules, costs of physician visits and physician-administered treatments; from published data, average wholesale prices of medications. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Estimated direct medical costs per complete clearance associated with different treatment options for condylomata acuminata. RESULTS: Mean direct medical costs per complete clearance are lowest for surgical excision ($285). Other low-cost modalities are loop electrosurgical excision procedure ($316), electrodesiccation ($347), carbon dioxide laser ($416), podofilox ($424), and pulsed-dye laser ($479). Higher-cost modalities are cryotherapy ($951), trichloroacetic acid ($986), imiquimod ($1255), podophyllum resin ($1632), and interferon alfa-2b ($6665). CONCLUSION: Surgical modalities, including excision, electrodesiccation, loop electrosurgical excision procedure, and laser, as well as podofilox are low-cost options for the treatment of condylomata acuminata.
Authors: C J N Lacey; R L Goodall; G Ragnarson Tennvall; R Maw; G R Kinghorn; P G Fisk; S Barton; I Byren Journal: Sex Transm Infect Date: 2003-08 Impact factor: 3.519
Authors: Monika Hampl; Eduard Huppertz; Olaf Schulz-Holstege; Patrick Kok; Sarah Schmitter Journal: BMC Infect Dis Date: 2011-03-22 Impact factor: 3.090