P Tornetta1, W Creevy. 1. Boston Medical Center, Massachusetts 02118, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the use of lag screw only fixation of noncomminuted oblique fractures of the lateral malleolus in patients younger than fifty years of age. DESIGN: Prospective evaluation. SETTING: Level I trauma center. PATIENTS AND PARTICIPANTS: Forty-seven ankle fractures with simple oblique patterns and no comminution that were long enough to accept two lag screws placed at least 1 centimeter apart were prospectively evaluated. All patients were younger than fifty years of age. There were twenty-three ligamentous SE4, eighteen bimalleolar SE4, and six PE4 fractures. INTERVENTION: Open reduction and internal fixation with lag screw only fixation of the lateral malleolus. MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS: Radiographic and clinical outcome parameters were compared with those of a cohort of patients previously treated at the same institutions using different techniques. RESULTS: Thirty-five patients' ankles were fixed with two lag screws, ten with three lag screws, and two with four lag screws. The incision for lag screw placement was 30 percent shorter and slightly more anterior than that in the comparison group. No patient lost reduction and there were no soft-tissue complications in the group. Follow up averaged 1.6 years for forty-two patients. One patient (2 percent) had complaints of lateral pain in the study, compared with 17 percent in the plate group. No patient fixed with lag screws had palpable hardware, as compared with 56 percent in the plate group. None had any restrictions in shoe wear, as compared with 15 percent in the plate group. No patient required screw removal, as compared with 31 percent in the plate group. There was no difference in radiographic outcome between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Lag screw only fixation is a useful and successful method for appropriately selected lateral malleolar fractures.
OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the use of lag screw only fixation of noncomminuted oblique fractures of the lateral malleolus in patients younger than fifty years of age. DESIGN: Prospective evaluation. SETTING: Level I trauma center. PATIENTS AND PARTICIPANTS: Forty-seven ankle fractures with simple oblique patterns and no comminution that were long enough to accept two lag screws placed at least 1 centimeter apart were prospectively evaluated. All patients were younger than fifty years of age. There were twenty-three ligamentous SE4, eighteen bimalleolar SE4, and six PE4 fractures. INTERVENTION: Open reduction and internal fixation with lag screw only fixation of the lateral malleolus. MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS: Radiographic and clinical outcome parameters were compared with those of a cohort of patients previously treated at the same institutions using different techniques. RESULTS: Thirty-five patients' ankles were fixed with two lag screws, ten with three lag screws, and two with four lag screws. The incision for lag screw placement was 30 percent shorter and slightly more anterior than that in the comparison group. No patient lost reduction and there were no soft-tissue complications in the group. Follow up averaged 1.6 years for forty-two patients. One patient (2 percent) had complaints of lateral pain in the study, compared with 17 percent in the plate group. No patient fixed with lag screws had palpable hardware, as compared with 56 percent in the plate group. None had any restrictions in shoe wear, as compared with 15 percent in the plate group. No patient required screw removal, as compared with 31 percent in the plate group. There was no difference in radiographic outcome between the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Lag screw only fixation is a useful and successful method for appropriately selected lateral malleolar fractures.
Authors: Robinson Esteves Santos Pires; Cyril Mauffrey; Marco Antônio Percope de Andrade; Leonardo Brandão Figueiredo; Vincenzo Giordano; João Carlos Belloti; Fernando Baldy dos Reis Journal: Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol Date: 2013-08-20