S H Hong1, S M Kim, J M Ahn, H W Chung, M J Shin, H S Kang. 1. Dept. of Radiology and Institute of Radiation Medicine, Seoul National University College of Medicine, 28 Yongon-dong, Chongno-gu, Seoul 110-744, Korea.
Abstract
PURPOSE: To assess magnetic resonance (MR) imaging features in differentiating tuberculous arthritis from pyogenic arthritis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Findings in 29 patients with tuberculous arthritis were compared with those of 13 patients with pyogenic arthritis. Bone erosion, marrow signal intensity, synovial lesion signal intensity, boundaries (smooth or irregular) for extraarticular extension of infection, and abscess rim enhancement (thin and smooth or thick and irregular) were analyzed. RESULTS: Bone erosion was more common in patients with tuberculous arthritis (24 [83%] of 29) than in those with pyogenic arthritis (six [46%] of 13) (P =.026), while subchondral marrow signal intensity abnormality was seen more frequently in patients with pyogenic arthritis (12 [92%] of 13) than in those with tuberculous arthritis (17 [59%] of 29) (P =.036). On T2-weighted images, there was no significant difference between the synovial lesion signal intensities of tuberculous arthritis and pyogenic arthritis. Lesions in 16 (70%) of 23 patients with tuberculous arthritis and two (17%) of 12 patients with pyogenic arthritis had smooth extraarticular boundaries, while those in seven (30%) of 23 patients with tuberculous arthritis and 10 (83%) of 12 patients with pyogenic arthritis had irregular boundaries (P =.005). Tuberculous abscesses (16 [100%] of 16) had thin and smooth rim enhancement, while most pyogenic abscesses (five [71%] of seven) had thick and irregular rims (P =.001). CONCLUSION: MR imaging of bone abnormalities, extraarticular lesions, and associated abscesses provides useful information in the differentiation of tuberculous arthritis and pyogenic arthritis.
PURPOSE: To assess magnetic resonance (MR) imaging features in differentiating tuberculous arthritis from pyogenic arthritis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Findings in 29 patients with tuberculous arthritis were compared with those of 13 patients with pyogenic arthritis. Bone erosion, marrow signal intensity, synovial lesion signal intensity, boundaries (smooth or irregular) for extraarticular extension of infection, and abscess rim enhancement (thin and smooth or thick and irregular) were analyzed. RESULTS: Bone erosion was more common in patients with tuberculous arthritis (24 [83%] of 29) than in those with pyogenic arthritis (six [46%] of 13) (P =.026), while subchondral marrow signal intensity abnormality was seen more frequently in patients with pyogenic arthritis (12 [92%] of 13) than in those with tuberculous arthritis (17 [59%] of 29) (P =.036). On T2-weighted images, there was no significant difference between the synovial lesion signal intensities of tuberculous arthritis and pyogenic arthritis. Lesions in 16 (70%) of 23 patients with tuberculous arthritis and two (17%) of 12 patients with pyogenic arthritis had smooth extraarticular boundaries, while those in seven (30%) of 23 patients with tuberculous arthritis and 10 (83%) of 12 patients with pyogenic arthritis had irregular boundaries (P =.005). Tuberculous abscesses (16 [100%] of 16) had thin and smooth rim enhancement, while most pyogenic abscesses (five [71%] of seven) had thick and irregular rims (P =.001). CONCLUSION: MR imaging of bone abnormalities, extraarticular lesions, and associated abscesses provides useful information in the differentiation of tuberculous arthritis and pyogenic arthritis.