EPR and ligand field studies of iron superoxide dismutases and iron-substituted manganese superoxide dismutases: relationships between electronic structure of the active site and activity.

The problem of metal selectivity of iron/manganese superoxide dismutases (SODs) is addressed through the electronic structures of active sites using electron paramagnetic resonance and ligand field calculations. Studies of wild-type iron(III) SOD (FeSOD) from Escherichia coli and from Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum and iron-substituted manganese(III) SOD (Fe(sub)MnSOD) from E. coli and from Serratia marcescens are reported. EPR spectroscopy of wild-type enzymes shows transitions within all three Kramers doublets identified by their g values. From the temperature dependence of the observed transitions, the zero-field splitting is found to be negative, D = -2 +/- 0.2 cm-1. The electronic structure is typical of a distorted trigonal bipyramid, all the EPR features being reproduced by ligand field analysis. This unique and necessary electronic structure characterizes wild-type enzymes whatever their classification from the amino acid sequence into iron or manganese types, as E. coli FeSOD or M. thermoautotrophicum FeSOD. In iron-substituted manganese SODs, reduced catalytic activity is found. We describe how inhomogeneity of all reported substituted MnSODs might explain the activity decrease. EPR spectra of substituted enzymes show several overlapping components. From simulation of these spectra, one component is identified which shares the same electronic structure of the wild-type FeSODs, with the proportion depending on pH. Ligand field calculations were performed to investigate distortions of the active site geometry which induce variation of the excitation energy of the lowest quartet state. The corresponding coupling between the ground state and the excited state is found to be maximum in the geometry of the native SODs. We conjecture that such coupling should be considered in the electron-transfer process and in the contribution of the typical electronic structure of FeSOD to the activity.