M Wolfensberger1, J A Haury, T Linder. 1. Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, University Hospital, Petersgraben 4, CH-4031, Basel, Switzerland. mwolfensberger@uhbs.ch
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Tonsillectomy is one of the most frequent as well as one of the most controversial operations performed in childhood. OBJECTIVE: To assess the expectations of parents before tonsillectomy and to assess their satisfaction 1 year after surgery. STUDY DESIGN: 664 children undergoing (adeno-)tonsillectomy were enrolled in a nation-wide prospective multicenter study. The child's medical history, clinical findings, and indication for tonsillectomy were recorded by the physicians at the time of surgery. The parents were asked to fill out a questionnaire and to list all symptoms from which they expected relief at the time of surgery and to assess the subjective benefit of the surgery 1 year post-operatively. Five-hundred and seventy six of the 664 patients' parents (87%) returned the follow-up questionnaire. RESULTS: 88% of the (adeno-)tonsillectomies were performed because of documented recurrent febrile tonsillitis or obstructive symptoms such as sleep apnea or snoring with restless sleep and daytime irritability. The number of episodes of febrile sore throat dropped from a mean of 6.7 in the year prior to surgery to a mean of 1.5 in the year after surgery (P<0.001). Obstructive symptoms disappeared in 80% of cases, 524 parents (91%) were satisfied with the benefit, 159 parents (28%) regretted not having arranged to have surgery performed earlier. CONCLUSION: Our study shows that parents assess the outcome of tonsillectomy not with regard to one main symptom (e.g. recurrent sore throat) but with regard to a number of complaints. It also shows a high rate (91%) of parent satisfaction after tonsillectomy. For the indications studied, tonsillectomy remains the treatment of choice and should not be delayed or even denied to those children.
BACKGROUND: Tonsillectomy is one of the most frequent as well as one of the most controversial operations performed in childhood. OBJECTIVE: To assess the expectations of parents before tonsillectomy and to assess their satisfaction 1 year after surgery. STUDY DESIGN: 664 children undergoing (adeno-)tonsillectomy were enrolled in a nation-wide prospective multicenter study. The child's medical history, clinical findings, and indication for tonsillectomy were recorded by the physicians at the time of surgery. The parents were asked to fill out a questionnaire and to list all symptoms from which they expected relief at the time of surgery and to assess the subjective benefit of the surgery 1 year post-operatively. Five-hundred and seventy six of the 664 patients' parents (87%) returned the follow-up questionnaire. RESULTS: 88% of the (adeno-)tonsillectomies were performed because of documented recurrent febrile tonsillitis or obstructive symptoms such as sleep apnea or snoring with restless sleep and daytime irritability. The number of episodes of febrile sore throat dropped from a mean of 6.7 in the year prior to surgery to a mean of 1.5 in the year after surgery (P<0.001). Obstructive symptoms disappeared in 80% of cases, 524 parents (91%) were satisfied with the benefit, 159 parents (28%) regretted not having arranged to have surgery performed earlier. CONCLUSION: Our study shows that parents assess the outcome of tonsillectomy not with regard to one main symptom (e.g. recurrent sore throat) but with regard to a number of complaints. It also shows a high rate (91%) of parent satisfaction after tonsillectomy. For the indications studied, tonsillectomy remains the treatment of choice and should not be delayed or even denied to those children.
Authors: Susan Redline; Raouf Amin; Dean Beebe; Ronald D Chervin; Susan L Garetz; Bruno Giordani; Carole L Marcus; Renee H Moore; Carol L Rosen; Raanan Arens; David Gozal; Eliot S Katz; Ronald B Mitchell; Hiren Muzumdar; H G Taylor; Nina Thomas; Susan Ellenberg Journal: Sleep Date: 2011-11-01 Impact factor: 5.849
Authors: Birgit K van Staaij; Emma H van den Akker; Maroeska M Rovers; Gerrit Jan Hordijk; Arno W Hoes; Anne G M Schilder Journal: BMJ Date: 2004-09-10
Authors: Wojciech Kukwa; Andrzej Kukwa; Adam Galazka; Anna M Czarnecka; Antoni Krzeski; Ewa Migacz; Stacey L Ishman Journal: Sleep Breath Date: 2015-03-06 Impact factor: 2.816