PURPOSE: The study goal was to assess the concordance of ictal surface-EEG and seizure semiology data in lateralizing intractable temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) and to examine the benefits of the combined use of these two methods. METHODS: We independently analyzed the ictal recordings and clinical symptoms associated with 262 seizures recorded in 59 TLE patients. Each seizure was lateralized on the basis of (i) its associated ictal surface-EEG pattern according to a predefined lateralization protocol and (ii) its associated ictal and postictal seizure semiology according to strictly defined clinical criteria. Individual patients were also lateralized based on these data. RESULTS: Ictal surface-EEG findings lateralized 62.6% of seizures and 64.4% of patients. Seizure semiology findings lateralized 46.2% of seizures and 78.0% of patients. There was a high degree of concordance between lateralizations based on these two methods, for both individual seizures and individual patients. Combination of the information from the two methods allowed for lateralization in a greater proportion of both seizures (79.8%) and patients (94.9%). Combined EEG-seizure lateralization was concordant with the side of operation in 33 of 34 patients who underwent successful surgery (Engel's surgical outcome class I/II). CONCLUSIONS: In TLE, there is a high agreement between the lateralization of individual seizures and patients, which is based on ictal surface-EEG findings and seizure semiology. Furthermore, combination of these two methods improves the lateralization of individual seizures and patients. Thus, standardized combined EEG-seizure analysis is a valuable noninvasive tool in the presurgical evaluation of TLE.
PURPOSE: The study goal was to assess the concordance of ictal surface-EEG and seizure semiology data in lateralizing intractable temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) and to examine the benefits of the combined use of these two methods. METHODS: We independently analyzed the ictal recordings and clinical symptoms associated with 262 seizures recorded in 59 TLEpatients. Each seizure was lateralized on the basis of (i) its associated ictal surface-EEG pattern according to a predefined lateralization protocol and (ii) its associated ictal and postictal seizure semiology according to strictly defined clinical criteria. Individual patients were also lateralized based on these data. RESULTS: Ictal surface-EEG findings lateralized 62.6% of seizures and 64.4% of patients. Seizure semiology findings lateralized 46.2% of seizures and 78.0% of patients. There was a high degree of concordance between lateralizations based on these two methods, for both individual seizures and individual patients. Combination of the information from the two methods allowed for lateralization in a greater proportion of both seizures (79.8%) and patients (94.9%). Combined EEG-seizure lateralization was concordant with the side of operation in 33 of 34 patients who underwent successful surgery (Engel's surgical outcome class I/II). CONCLUSIONS: In TLE, there is a high agreement between the lateralization of individual seizures and patients, which is based on ictal surface-EEG findings and seizure semiology. Furthermore, combination of these two methods improves the lateralization of individual seizures and patients. Thus, standardized combined EEG-seizure analysis is a valuable noninvasive tool in the presurgical evaluation of TLE.
Authors: Carmen Barba; F Doglietto; L De Luca; G Faraca; C Marra; M Meglio; G F Rossi; G Colicchio Journal: J Neurol Date: 2005-02-23 Impact factor: 4.849