OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether, during injections of sterile water, there is any difference in perceived pain between intracutaneous and subcutaneous injections. DESIGN: Blind controlled trial with cross-over design. SETTING: Göteborg and Skövde, Sweden. PARTICIPANTS: One hundred healthy female volunteers. METHODS: The women were randomised into two groups and subjected to two trials, within one week of each other. During the first trial one group (n = 50) received the intracutaneous injection first, followed by the subcutaneous injection. The second group (n = 50) was given the subcutaneous injection first, followed by intracutaneous injection. In both groups all the injections were given in reverse order during the second trial. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Experienced pain during the administration of sterile water injections, measured by visual analogue scale. RESULTS: The analysis showed intracutaneous injections to be significantly more painful than subcutaneous injections, even after adjusting for injection day and for left/right site of injection (mean 60.8 vs 41.3, P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that the less painful subcutaneous injection technique should be used.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether, during injections of sterile water, there is any difference in perceived pain between intracutaneous and subcutaneous injections. DESIGN: Blind controlled trial with cross-over design. SETTING: Göteborg and Skövde, Sweden. PARTICIPANTS: One hundred healthy female volunteers. METHODS: The women were randomised into two groups and subjected to two trials, within one week of each other. During the first trial one group (n = 50) received the intracutaneous injection first, followed by the subcutaneous injection. The second group (n = 50) was given the subcutaneous injection first, followed by intracutaneous injection. In both groups all the injections were given in reverse order during the second trial. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Experienced pain during the administration of sterile water injections, measured by visual analogue scale. RESULTS: The analysis showed intracutaneous injections to be significantly more painful than subcutaneous injections, even after adjusting for injection day and for left/right site of injection (mean 60.8 vs 41.3, P < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that the less painful subcutaneous injection technique should be used.