BACKGROUND: The present study modeled data from a large series of experiments originally designed to investigate the influence of time, dose, and fractionation on early and late pathologic endpoints in rat small intestine after localized irradiation. The objective was to obtain satisfactory descriptions of the regenerative response to injury together with the possible relationships between early and late endpoints. METHODS: Two- and 26-week pathologic radiation injury data in groups of Sprague-Dawley rats irradiated with 27 different fractionation schedules were modeled using the incomplete repair (IR) version of the linear-quadratic model with or without various time correction models. The following time correction models were tested: (1) No time correction; (2) A simple exponential (SE) regenerative response beginning at an arbitrary time after starting treatment; and (3) A bi-exponential response with its commencement linked to accumulated cellular depletion and fraction size (the 'intelligent response model' [INTR]). Goodness of fit of the various models was assessed by correlating the predicted biological effective dose for each dose group with the observed radiation injury score. RESULTS: (1) The incomplete repair model without time correction did not provide a satisfactory description of either the 2- or 26-week data. (2) The models using SE time correction performed better, providing modest descriptions of the data. (3) The INTR model provided reasonable descriptions of both the 2- and 26-week data, confirming a treatment time dependence of both early and late pathological endpoints. (4) The most satisfactory descriptions of the data by the INTR model were obtained when the regenerative response was assumed to cease 2 weeks after irradiation rather than at the end of irradiation. A fraction-size-dependent delay of the regenerative response was also suggested in the best fitting models. (5) Late endpoints were associated with low-fractionation sensitivity and treatment-time dependence even in animal groups that exhibited minimal early mucosal reactions. CONCLUSION: Radiation injury scores in this rat small intestinal experimental model cannot be adequately described without time correction. 'Consequential' mechanisms contribute to the development of late effects, even in animals that do not develop severe early mucosal injuries. The initiation of the regenerative response is subject to a fraction-size-dependent mitotic delay and is linked to the level of accumulated cellular depletion. The response does not cease at the end of therapy but probably continues until maximal healing has taken place.
BACKGROUND: The present study modeled data from a large series of experiments originally designed to investigate the influence of time, dose, and fractionation on early and late pathologic endpoints in rat small intestine after localized irradiation. The objective was to obtain satisfactory descriptions of the regenerative response to injury together with the possible relationships between early and late endpoints. METHODS: Two- and 26-week pathologic radiation injury data in groups of Sprague-Dawley rats irradiated with 27 different fractionation schedules were modeled using the incomplete repair (IR) version of the linear-quadratic model with or without various time correction models. The following time correction models were tested: (1) No time correction; (2) A simple exponential (SE) regenerative response beginning at an arbitrary time after starting treatment; and (3) A bi-exponential response with its commencement linked to accumulated cellular depletion and fraction size (the 'intelligent response model' [INTR]). Goodness of fit of the various models was assessed by correlating the predicted biological effective dose for each dose group with the observed radiation injury score. RESULTS: (1) The incomplete repair model without time correction did not provide a satisfactory description of either the 2- or 26-week data. (2) The models using SE time correction performed better, providing modest descriptions of the data. (3) The INTR model provided reasonable descriptions of both the 2- and 26-week data, confirming a treatment time dependence of both early and late pathological endpoints. (4) The most satisfactory descriptions of the data by the INTR model were obtained when the regenerative response was assumed to cease 2 weeks after irradiation rather than at the end of irradiation. A fraction-size-dependent delay of the regenerative response was also suggested in the best fitting models. (5) Late endpoints were associated with low-fractionation sensitivity and treatment-time dependence even in animal groups that exhibited minimal early mucosal reactions. CONCLUSION:Radiation injury scores in this rat small intestinal experimental model cannot be adequately described without time correction. 'Consequential' mechanisms contribute to the development of late effects, even in animals that do not develop severe early mucosal injuries. The initiation of the regenerative response is subject to a fraction-size-dependent mitotic delay and is linked to the level of accumulated cellular depletion. The response does not cease at the end of therapy but probably continues until maximal healing has taken place.
Authors: H K Awwad; M Lotayef; T Shouman; A C Begg; G Wilson; S M Bentzen; H Abd El-Moneim; S Eissa Journal: Br J Cancer Date: 2002-02-12 Impact factor: 7.640