R Sahjpaul1, M Girotti. 1. Department of Clinical Neurological Sciences, London Health Sciences Center, Ontario, Canada.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to obtain information from Canadian neurosurgeons regarding their opinions on, and utilization of, intracranial pressure (ICP) monitoring for severe traumatic brain injury (TBI). METHODS: A brief survey was sent to practicing Canadian neurosurgeons questioning them about their utilization of, and confidence in, intracranial pressure monitoring in the management of patients with severe TBI. RESULTS: One hundred and ninety-six surveys were mailed. There were 103 responses for a response rate of 52.6%. The vast majority of responding neurosurgeons (98.1%) utilized ICP monitoring in the management of patients with severe TBI, with most (63.4%) using it in more than 75% of their patients, 14.9% using it in 50-75% of patients, 14.9% in 25-50% of patients, and 6.9% using it in less than 25% of patients. The level of confidence that routine monitoring improves outcome from severe TBI ranged from 23.3% having a low level of confidence, 56.3% having an intermediate level of confidence, to 20.4% having a high level of confidence. Most respondents (78.6%) felt that some form of prospective trial evaluating the role of ICP monitoring in improving outcome from severe TBI was warranted; 17.4% felt such a trial was not warranted and 3.9% were uncertain. CONCLUSIONS: While ICP monitoring has gained almost universal acceptance among responding Canadian neurosurgeons, their level of confidence that routine monitoring improves outcome from severe TBI was quite variable, with only 20.4% of respondents having a high level of confidence. Over 75% of respondents felt that some form of prospective trial evaluating the utility of ICP monitoring is warranted. This information is being used in consideration of a prospective trial addressing this issue.
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to obtain information from Canadian neurosurgeons regarding their opinions on, and utilization of, intracranial pressure (ICP) monitoring for severe traumatic brain injury (TBI). METHODS: A brief survey was sent to practicing Canadian neurosurgeons questioning them about their utilization of, and confidence in, intracranial pressure monitoring in the management of patients with severe TBI. RESULTS: One hundred and ninety-six surveys were mailed. There were 103 responses for a response rate of 52.6%. The vast majority of responding neurosurgeons (98.1%) utilized ICP monitoring in the management of patients with severe TBI, with most (63.4%) using it in more than 75% of their patients, 14.9% using it in 50-75% of patients, 14.9% in 25-50% of patients, and 6.9% using it in less than 25% of patients. The level of confidence that routine monitoring improves outcome from severe TBI ranged from 23.3% having a low level of confidence, 56.3% having an intermediate level of confidence, to 20.4% having a high level of confidence. Most respondents (78.6%) felt that some form of prospective trial evaluating the role of ICP monitoring in improving outcome from severe TBI was warranted; 17.4% felt such a trial was not warranted and 3.9% were uncertain. CONCLUSIONS: While ICP monitoring has gained almost universal acceptance among responding Canadian neurosurgeons, their level of confidence that routine monitoring improves outcome from severe TBI was quite variable, with only 20.4% of respondents having a high level of confidence. Over 75% of respondents felt that some form of prospective trial evaluating the utility of ICP monitoring is warranted. This information is being used in consideration of a prospective trial addressing this issue.
Authors: Randall M Chesnut; Nancy Temkin; Walter Videtta; Gustavo Petroni; Silvia Lujan; Jim Pridgeon; Sureyya Dikmen; Kelley Chaddock; Jason Barber; Joan Machamer; Nahuel Guadagnoli; Peter Hendrickson; Sergio Aguilera; Victor Alanis; Manuel Enrique Bello Quezada; Ermitaño Bautista Coronel; Luis Alberto Bustamante; Armando C Cacciatori; Carlos Javier Carricondo; Felipe Carvajal; Rafael Davila; Mario Dominguez; Jairo Antonio Figueroa Melgarejo; Maria Martha Fillipi; Daniel A Godoy; Delia Cristina Gomez; Angel J Lacerda Gallardo; Juan Antonio Guerra Garcia; Gustavo la Fuente Zerain; Luis Arturo Lavadenz Cuientas; Cecilio Lequipe; Gerardo Vicente Grajales Yuca; Manuel Jibaja Vega; Michael Eduardo Kessler; Hubiel J López Delgado; Freddy Sandi Lora; Ana Maria Mazzola; Roberto Merida Maldonado; Natascha Mezquia de Pedro; J Ricardo Martínez Zubieta; Julio C Mijangos Méndez; Jacobo Mora; Johnny Marcelo Ochoa Parra; Perla B Pahnke; Jorge Paranhos; Gustavo R Piñero; Francisco A Rivadeneira Pilacuán; Mario Napoleon Mendez Rivera; Ricardo Luis Romero Figueroa; Andres M Rubiano; Alexandra Matilde Saraguro Orozco; Juan Ignacio Silesky Jiménez; Luis Silva Naranjo; Caridad Soler Morejon; Zulma Urbina Journal: J Neurotrauma Date: 2020-03-04 Impact factor: 5.269
Authors: Randall M Chesnut; Nancy Temkin; Nancy Carney; Sureyya Dikmen; Carlos Rondina; Walter Videtta; Gustavo Petroni; Silvia Lujan; Jim Pridgeon; Jason Barber; Joan Machamer; Kelley Chaddock; Juanita M Celix; Marianna Cherner; Terence Hendrix Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2012-12-12 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Randall M Chesnut; Nancy Temkin; Sureyya Dikmen; Carlos Rondina; Walter Videtta; Gustavo Petroni; Silvia Lujan; Victor Alanis; Antonio Falcao; Gustavo de la Fuenta; Luis Gonzalez; Manuel Jibaja; Arturo Lavarden; Freddy Sandi; Roberto Mérida; Ricardo Romero; Jim Pridgeon; Jason Barber; Joan Machamer; Kelley Chaddock Journal: J Neurotrauma Date: 2017-09-26 Impact factor: 5.269
Authors: Walter Mauritz; Heinz Steltzer; Peter Bauer; Lorenz Dolanski-Aghamanoukjan; Philipp Metnitz Journal: Intensive Care Med Date: 2008-03-26 Impact factor: 17.440
Authors: Aziz S Alali; Robert A Fowler; Todd G Mainprize; Damon C Scales; Alexander Kiss; Charles de Mestral; Joel G Ray; Avery B Nathens Journal: J Neurotrauma Date: 2013-07-11 Impact factor: 5.269
Authors: Randall M Chesnut; Nancy Temkin; Sureyya Dikmen; Carlos Rondina; Walter Videtta; Silvia Lujan; Gustavo Petroni; James Pridgeon; Jason Barber; Joan Machamer; Kelley Chaddock; Juanita M Celix; Marianna Cherner; Terence Hendrix Journal: Surg Neurol Int Date: 2015-07-02
Authors: Cesar Biselli Ferreira; Estevão Bassi; Lucas Lucena; Hernandez Carreta; Leandro Costa Miranda; Paulo Fernando Guimarães Mazorcchi Tierno; Robson Luis Amorim; Fernando Godinho Zampieri; Luis Marcelo Sá Malbouisson Journal: Rev Bras Ter Intensiva Date: 2015 Oct-Dec