Can succinylcholine be abandoned?

The elective use of succinylcholine in anesthesia has largely been abandoned because of unwanted side effects. Alternatives now exist for short, intermediate, or long elective surgical procedures. NMBDs are frequently used only to facilitate tracheal intubation; rapacuronium fills an important niche particularly for a short elective case (e.g., same-day surgery). However, an equally critical issue is whether there is a reliable replacement for succinylcholine for the treatment of laryngospasm or for rapid sequence induction in patients with "full stomachs." Succinylcholine produces more intense block in a shorter time at the laryngeal muscles, compared with the adductor pollicis, compared with vecuronium, rocuronium, mivacurium, and rapacuronium (30). Although most intubations can be facilitated with 80%-90% neuromuscular block, the ideal relaxant for a rapid sequence induction should produce uniformly complete neuromuscular blockade in 1 min. Variability in the degree of neuromuscular blockade and onset time can be compared for various relaxants by using the standard deviation (Table 1), the coefficient of variation (Table 2), or a plot of the degree of maximum neuromuscular block and the time to maximum block. Figure 1 shows such a plot for mivacurium (13). There is less variability in the maximum block at the larger dose of rapacuronium but still variability in onset time. Further studies will be important in defining the role of rapacuronium for rapid sequence induction in various clinical settings.