L Smolak1, S K Murnen, A E Ruble. 1. Department of Psychology, Kenyon College, Gambier, OH 43022, USA. smolak@kenyon.edu
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The relationship between athletic participation and eating problems is examined using meta-analysis. Both the risk and protective elements of athletic participation are considered. METHOD: Data from 34 studies were used to examine the overall relationship between athletic participation and eating problems. Relationships for specific sports, elite athletes, and various age groups are also examined. RESULTS: Athletes appeared to be somewhat more at risk for eating problems than nonathletes. This was especially true of dancers. Significant effects did not emerge for gymnasts. Elite athletes, especially those in sports emphasizing thinness, were at risk. Nonelite athletes, especially in high school, had reduced risk of eating problems compared to controls. Body dissatisfaction was lower in athletes. CONCLUSION: There appear to be circumstances under which sports participation by women constitutes a risk factor for certain elements of eating problems. In other situations, athletic participation may be protective against eating problems. Copyright 2000 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
OBJECTIVE: The relationship between athletic participation and eating problems is examined using meta-analysis. Both the risk and protective elements of athletic participation are considered. METHOD: Data from 34 studies were used to examine the overall relationship between athletic participation and eating problems. Relationships for specific sports, elite athletes, and various age groups are also examined. RESULTS: Athletes appeared to be somewhat more at risk for eating problems than nonathletes. This was especially true of dancers. Significant effects did not emerge for gymnasts. Elite athletes, especially those in sports emphasizing thinness, were at risk. Nonelite athletes, especially in high school, had reduced risk of eating problems compared to controls. Body dissatisfaction was lower in athletes. CONCLUSION: There appear to be circumstances under which sports participation by women constitutes a risk factor for certain elements of eating problems. In other situations, athletic participation may be protective against eating problems. Copyright 2000 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Authors: C L Otis; M Crespo; C T Flygare; P R Johnston; A Keber; D Lloyd-Kolkin; J Loehr; K Martin; B M Pluim; A Quinn; P Roetert; K A Stroia; P C Terry Journal: Br J Sports Med Date: 2006-05 Impact factor: 13.800
Authors: Christine M Bonci; Leslie J Bonci; Lorita R Granger; Craig L Johnson; Robert M Malina; Leslie W Milne; Randa R Ryan; Erin M Vanderbunt Journal: J Athl Train Date: 2008 Jan-Mar Impact factor: 2.860