B S Alper1, P R Lewis. 1. Pennsylvania State University/Good Samaritan Hospital Family and Community Medicine Residency Program, Lebanon, USA. alper@earthlink.net
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Our goal was to determine if any treatment of acute herpes zoster alters the incidence or duration of postherpetic neuralgia (PHN), a common sequela in elderly patients. SEARCH STRATEGY: We systematically searched MEDLINE and The Cochrane Library. We also examined the reference lists of identified trials and reviews. SELECTION CRITERIA: We included all randomized controlled trials of treatments of zoster published in English that included assessment of pain at any time after rash healing. DATA COLLECTION/ANALYSIS: Forty-two trials met inclusion criteria, and 2 reviewers independently evaluated them for methodologic quality and the statistical and clinical significance of results. MAIN RESULTS: Four placebo-controlled trials of oral acyclovir with 692 patients provided marginal evidence for reduction in pain incidence at 1 to 3 months following zoster onset. Famciclovir significantly reduced duration but not incidence of PHN in one placebo-controlled trial of 419 patients. Valacyclovir significantly reduced duration but not incidence of PHN in one acyclovir-controlled trial of 1141 patients. Steroids had no effect on PHN. Amitriptyline for 90 days reduced pain incidence at 6 months in one placebo-controlled trial of 80 patients. A single trial of percutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (PENS) in 50 patients suggested a decrease in pain incidence at 3 and 6 months compared with famciclovir. CONCLUSIONS: There is limited evidence that current interventions prevent or shorten PHN. Famciclovir and valacyclovir have been shown to reduce the duration of PHN in single published trials. Well-designed and larger trials of amitriptyline and PENS should be conducted.
OBJECTIVE: Our goal was to determine if any treatment of acute herpes zoster alters the incidence or duration of postherpetic neuralgia (PHN), a common sequela in elderly patients. SEARCH STRATEGY: We systematically searched MEDLINE and The Cochrane Library. We also examined the reference lists of identified trials and reviews. SELECTION CRITERIA: We included all randomized controlled trials of treatments of zoster published in English that included assessment of pain at any time after rash healing. DATA COLLECTION/ANALYSIS: Forty-two trials met inclusion criteria, and 2 reviewers independently evaluated them for methodologic quality and the statistical and clinical significance of results. MAIN RESULTS: Four placebo-controlled trials of oral acyclovir with 692 patients provided marginal evidence for reduction in pain incidence at 1 to 3 months following zoster onset. Famciclovir significantly reduced duration but not incidence of PHN in one placebo-controlled trial of 419 patients. Valacyclovir significantly reduced duration but not incidence of PHN in one acyclovir-controlled trial of 1141 patients. Steroids had no effect on PHN. Amitriptyline for 90 days reduced pain incidence at 6 months in one placebo-controlled trial of 80 patients. A single trial of percutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (PENS) in 50 patients suggested a decrease in pain incidence at 3 and 6 months compared with famciclovir. CONCLUSIONS: There is limited evidence that current interventions prevent or shorten PHN. Famciclovir and valacyclovir have been shown to reduce the duration of PHN in single published trials. Well-designed and larger trials of amitriptyline and PENS should be conducted.
Authors: Ana M Cebrián-Cuenca; Javier Díez-Domingo; María San-Martín Rodríguez; Joan Puig-Barberá; Jorge Navarro-Pérez Journal: BMC Fam Pract Date: 2010-05-06 Impact factor: 2.497